List of articles (by subject)
-
Open Access Article
1 - Explanation of the role of gamification on job satisfaction and employee motivation (case study: cosmetic industry)
Sahar Vatankhah Mohammad MasumThe purpose of this study is explanation of the role of gamification on job satisfaction and employee motivation in cosmetic industry. This research is a positivist nature with a quantitative approach. Also, this research is descriptive and in type of field studies, and MoreThe purpose of this study is explanation of the role of gamification on job satisfaction and employee motivation in cosmetic industry. This research is a positivist nature with a quantitative approach. Also, this research is descriptive and in type of field studies, and in terms of research approach, is a quantitative research. Target population of this study is all staff of marketing and sales units in member of iran cosmetic industries association whose scope of activity is in tehran province. In this study for sampling, cluster sampling method has been used. Also in this study, we used krejcie and morgan tables to determine the sample size and 350 members of the target population have been investigated. In this research, two methods of library and field methods (a standard questionnaire consisting of 13 items) have been used for data collection. In this study in order to assurance of the reliability of the measurement instruments, cronbach's alpha was used. And for validation content validity(content validity ratio and content validity index) was used. Also in order to investigate the relationship between variables and data analysis, paired-samples T test and SPSS software have been used. The results showed that gamification has an effect on job satisfaction and employee motivation. Manuscript profile -
Open Access Article
2 - Presentation of Employee Satisfaction Assessment Model from EMS (LMS)
Sima Soofi Mohammad Javad Ershadi Ali Naimi SadighToday, the e-learning system has become an integral part of a learning system at the cutting edge. The staff of the organization of registration of documents and real estate in order to increase productivity and especially reduce the waste of time and energy, as well as MoreToday, the e-learning system has become an integral part of a learning system at the cutting edge. The staff of the organization of registration of documents and real estate in order to increase productivity and especially reduce the waste of time and energy, as well as the use of high user levels and flexibility in receiving educational services are keen to use e-learning services, and this has led to the expansion of this type of training in the organization. Is. The present study has developed various aspects of the evaluation of the e-learning system based on the ECVAL model. The organization of registration of documents in view of the geographical dispersion of satellite organizations and the necessity of using this system have been studied in this study. The developed model consists of various indexes such as apparent standards, content, security, compatibility with virtual instruments, etc. To this end, a 3D questionnaire has been designed and distributed. In this questionnaire, questions were asked to evaluate employee satisfaction and distributed among 80 employees of this organization. The results of the evaluation and statistical analysis show that the apparent character is of the highest importance to the users, and the security issue is of low importance to them. Finally, executive suggestions were made to improve the quality of the e-learning system. Manuscript profile -
Open Access Article
3 - Identify and prioritize the informal learning methods of Secondary school teachers
Mohsen Dibaei saberWhat is certain about formal and informal learning is a remarkable difference in the contribution of these two types of learning. So that different researches show that, the greatest share of teachers' learning is achieved through informal learning methods. Therefore, t MoreWhat is certain about formal and informal learning is a remarkable difference in the contribution of these two types of learning. So that different researches show that, the greatest share of teachers' learning is achieved through informal learning methods. Therefore, the purpose of this research is to identify the informal learning methods of Secondary school teachers. For this purpose, using event-driven approach to narration and interviews of experience in dozens of qualified teachers has been identified in relation to their informal learning methods.After three-step coding, a total of seven categories and 15 learning methods were identified for Secondary school teachers.In order to prioritize the informal learning methods of Secondary school teachers, 356 questionnaires have been distributed and collected. Friedman test results show learning methods for engaging with experienced and empowered teachers, learning through interaction and talking with specialist friends outside the school and the region, learning through problem solving in academic circles, learning Through conducting a personalized research on the problem in the class, four priority learning methods are among Secondary school teachers. Manuscript profile -
Open Access Article
4 - Modeling the adequacy of staff training based on the analytical approach of dynamic systems Case Study: Social Security Organization staff in West Azerbaijan Province
Banafshe Shafei Maryam Sameri Javad KeyhanObjective: This research is a scenario-based study to evaluate the training adequacy model of the Social Security Organization staff. Methodology: In this study, the research method is a combination of theme analysis and dynamic systems. The study population was the We MoreObjective: This research is a scenario-based study to evaluate the training adequacy model of the Social Security Organization staff. Methodology: In this study, the research method is a combination of theme analysis and dynamic systems. The study population was the West Azerbaijan Social Security Organization and the experts of An open interview was used to gather information using the library method and study of documents and also to better understand the subject Thus, the study is exploratory in nature and data collection is field-based.. The analysis of the data obtained using the dynamic systems approach was performed in the software environment (Vensim) and through this method the behavior of the system and the impact of different policies on it were tested and analyzed. Results: The results showed that the reference model of training adequacy could in no way cover future training goals, It is necessary to provide the best policies for achieving training competence in the Social Security Organization of West Azerbaijan Province using different scenarios.. From 10 scenarios, it was found that surrogacy scenarios in training, feeling effective with psychological empowerment and need assessment in process management is the best policy for enhancing training competence. Conclusion: Psychological empowerment and the feeling of being effective in staff are time-consuming, but if one creates this sense of human capital's potentials and abilities flourish and at the stage of mental development, one's ability to solve, interpret, change, analyze, Criticism and evaluation will be provided to the organization in order to achieve training competence. Keywords: Training Adequacy, Dynamic System, Psychological Empowerment, Process Management Manuscript profile -
Open Access Article
5 - Developing and validating of talent Identification Model of Faculty Members at Comprehensive Universities with regional performance level (Case: university of Lorestan)
Khodayar abili unes romiani javad porkarimi saeid frahbakhshThe main purpose of this research is to develop a talent Identification Model of Faculty Members at Comprehensive Universities with regional performance level with using a mixed research method. In the qualitative section, the statistical population consisted of academi MoreThe main purpose of this research is to develop a talent Identification Model of Faculty Members at Comprehensive Universities with regional performance level with using a mixed research method. In the qualitative section, the statistical population consisted of academic and executive experts that 19 of whom were purposefully selected and interviewed in a semi-structured manner. Also, in the quantitative section, the statistical population consisted of all faculty members of University of Lorestan (307) that 110 individuals were selected Using stratified random sampling method as sample. In the qualitative section, to collect data Semi-structured interviews and in quantitative section tow questionnaire were used. The results showed talent Identification Model consist of three Component: educational dimension (Scientific mastery, effective teaching, and learning), research dimension (Applying knowledge, research capability, writing and scientific publication, analysis) and consultation dimension (consultation to business environments, consultation to students and consultation to the community). It was also found that all observable and latent variables have a factor loading above .70. Manuscript profile -
Open Access Article
6 - Identification and evaluation of factors influencing the culture of E-learning for adoption of IT and implementation of SCRM
میثم کیوانی Mehdi Zrak hossein momeni mahmouei Ali HosseinzadehThe purpose of this study was to identify and evaluate the effective factors of e-learning culture for IT adoption and SCRM deployment in Shargh Cement Company. The qualitative and objective research approach is a thematic exploratory study in which 25 managers of sharg MoreThe purpose of this study was to identify and evaluate the effective factors of e-learning culture for IT adoption and SCRM deployment in Shargh Cement Company. The qualitative and objective research approach is a thematic exploratory study in which 25 managers of shargh cement and experts in this field were selected through semi-structured interviews through simple random sampling method. Findings The research identifies seven major themes, or factors, affecting e-learning culture for IT adoption and SCRM deployment. The seven themes are structural factors, behavioral factors, environmental factors, processes, outputs, effects and outcomes. 146 codes were extracted from these main themes in the context of the interviews.From these main themes, 75 concepts were extracted based on conceptual similarity, categorization, and composition. Then, the role of each of the subcategories in creating an e-learning culture for IT adoption and SCRM deployment was examined. Manuscript profile -
Open Access Article
7 - Identifying Challenges to Development of Distance Education from the Perspective of Payame Noor University Professors
Manijeh AhmadiThe purpose of the research is to identify the challenges of distance education development from the perspective of professors of Payame Noor University. The research method is qualitative in terms of purpose and in terms of data collection. In this research, after purp MoreThe purpose of the research is to identify the challenges of distance education development from the perspective of professors of Payame Noor University. The research method is qualitative in terms of purpose and in terms of data collection. In this research, after purposeful sampling and reviewing documents and research, the process of interviewing key and informed experts continued until the full identification, description, and characterization of the dimensions, components and indices and theoretical saturation were achieved. In order to determine the logical framework of the collected data, the steps of identifying, taking notes and classifying the concepts were performed. To this end, the collected information and texts were reviewed and categorized into major categories. Finally, the categories were reviewed and the duplicates removed, similar and smaller mergers and dimensions of the specific topic were categorized within the obtained components and indices. Based on the results, two-dimensional extraction model, 7 components, and 45 indices were extracted for university e-learning challenges. After finalizing the data analysis and extracting the conceptual model, the validity of the model was evaluated with 10 experts and university experts in a focus group on dimensions, components and indicators of agreement. Manuscript profile -
Open Access Article
8 - Conceptual Model of Corporate University evolution and development
Akram Talebi Saeed Ghiasi Nodooshan abbas abbaspour Ali khorsandi TaskoohOrganizational university is the link between an organization and specialized knowledge; and is known as one of the most efficient mechanisms for global competition. Regarding the closing or merging announcements of some of the above universities into some public univer MoreOrganizational university is the link between an organization and specialized knowledge; and is known as one of the most efficient mechanisms for global competition. Regarding the closing or merging announcements of some of the above universities into some public universities, as well as other issues the universities are involved, the purpose of the present research is to extract effective factors of the universities evolution and development in Iran. Therefore, research data were collected and coded through interviewing with 12 experts of organizational university area and university administrators using Grounded Theory Method. Research findings show that several organizational and academic factors may influence university performance including clarifying the purpose of university, organization and university CEOs, finance, and level of participation, learners, structure flexibility, educational programs, and knowledge management. University independence and privatization are also university external effective factors. It is recommended that private sector is enabled for effective and economic operation through clarifying and proper implementing of Article 44 of Constitution; then, the organizational university would shed light to the individual and organizational growth and development. Manuscript profile -
Open Access Article
9 - Identification of the solutions for implementing and improving staff training using the gamification approach
Seyed Mohammad Mahmoudi Farideh Shayani Asef KarimiToday, special attention is paid to training methods in organizations, that way the most lack of access to training objectives are due to weaknesses in the training methods. One of the newest methods is using the related concepts the game to design the training courses. MoreToday, special attention is paid to training methods in organizations, that way the most lack of access to training objectives are due to weaknesses in the training methods. One of the newest methods is using the related concepts the game to design the training courses. The games can be used and extended as patterns in learning. This survey has been done to find the gamification implementing approaches in teaching staff, by using the qualitative method and semi-structured interviews with experts in training and gamification precinct whom selected with snowball method. Data analysis has been done in two sects: in the first one, the data obtained from the interviews were analyzed by using Theme Analysis method, and in the second one, the entropy Shannon method has been used for prioritize the approaches. As a result, we found the approaches which were divided to six kinds such as: cognitive, emotional, social, preparing, educational, and organization, and approaches were also prioritized. It can be concluded from these findings which the approaches presentation to organizations educational courses holding solutions can improve the employees motivations and spirits and also can increases their participation and performance, so it can enhance the organization effectiveness. Manuscript profile -
Open Access Article
10 - Presentation Leaders' Self-Development Model: A Synthesis of Research
mahdi sahraei beiranvand Gholamreza Shams Morkani Abasalt Khorasani Mohammad sadegh Khayatian yazdiThis research aims to present a model of leaders' self-development based on the synthesis of past research. The research method is qualitativeand it's kind of a synthesis. The statistical population of the study includes researches and studies conducted in the period 19 MoreThis research aims to present a model of leaders' self-development based on the synthesis of past research. The research method is qualitativeand it's kind of a synthesis. The statistical population of the study includes researches and studies conducted in the period 1970-2020 in the field of self-development leadership 2890 that after various stages of elimination and reduction, 61 research samples were selected. Related resources were coded by three-step open, axial, and selective coding. Reliability, validity and credibility of the findings were used to evaluate the quality of coding, and the Kappa coefficient of coefficient for agreement between the evaluators was 0.75. According to the findings of this study, the model of leaders' self-development process is that self-development factors through one of a variety of self-development (structured, guided or individual) and using one of self-development mechanisms (self-leadership, self-management, self-regulation and self-directed learning) shapes the process of leaders' self-development. Manuscript profile -
Open Access Article
11 - Presentation of Human Resource Development Model Based on the Transformational Approach (meta-synthesis study)
Hamid Zare Azadeh Rasouli porshokouh Hasan Zaree Matin Hamid Reza YazdaniOne of the important and main processes of human resource management is human resource development in the organization. Human resource development activities in organizations fall into three categories: transactional, traditional, and transformational. A transformationa MoreOne of the important and main processes of human resource management is human resource development in the organization. Human resource development activities in organizations fall into three categories: transactional, traditional, and transformational. A transformational approach focuses on result-oriented and performance-based strategies and helps the organization achieve business goals and strategies. While in the transactional and traditional approach, the basic processes of staff training and learning are discussed.Given the importance of human resource development measures in a transformational approach. This study seeks to answer a key question, presenting a model of human resource development based on transformational approach and four important and interrelated questions about what, why and how to develop human resources based on transformational approach as well as the inputs needed for this approach. the systematic review method has been used in collecting literature and qualitative interpretation meta-synthesis in composition and interpretation. In this study, 31 main articles, books and dissertations were analyzed during the search, composition and interpretation process Which eventually led to the answer to three important research sub-questions. On the other hand, by referring to the relevant literature on this approach and after answering the questions, an attempt was made to present a model for human resources development based on a transformational approach. Manuscript profile -
Open Access Article
12 - Identifying the behavioral dimensions and components of entrepreneurial coaches
Mohammad Azizi hamid hosseinlo yousef vakiliObjective: Today's business community needs entrepreneurship coaches more than anything else. Entrepreneurial coaches encourage entrepreneurs to turn their strategic vision into action. This research aims to identify the components of entrepreneurial coaches in small an MoreObjective: Today's business community needs entrepreneurship coaches more than anything else. Entrepreneurial coaches encourage entrepreneurs to turn their strategic vision into action. This research aims to identify the components of entrepreneurial coaches in small and medium businesses of the pharmaceutical industry. Method: Developmental-applied research method and qualitative data collection were used. In order to identify the components of entrepreneurial coaches in small and medium businesses, 16 experienced and knowledgeable experts in the field of coaching who were selected in a purposeful manner and specifically from the snowball technique. Open and central coding has been used to analyze the data. Results: The analysis of the findings showed that the factors and components of entrepreneurial coaches in small and medium businesses consist of three factors: knowledge and skills of coaching, psychological characteristics and actions of entrepreneurial coaches. Manuscript profile -
Open Access Article
13 - identifying the critical success factors for coaching in organizations with a meta-synthesis approach: providing a model
Sajad Gharloghi Abasalt Khorasani Gholamreza Shams Moorkani Behrooz GhelichleeThe purpose of this study is to identify the key factors of coaching success in the organization. This study also provides a comprehensive model for coaching success factors.This study was conducted in the framework of a qualitative approach meta-synthesis methode with MoreThe purpose of this study is to identify the key factors of coaching success in the organization. This study also provides a comprehensive model for coaching success factors.This study was conducted in the framework of a qualitative approach meta-synthesis methode with the seven-step approach of Sandolowski and Barso (2009). The study population of the present study includes all Persian and English researches and studies published in the field of coaching between 2000 and 2020. In this regard, keywords related to the purpose of the research were searched. Then, the obtained articles and documents were examined using purposive sampling method, according to the acceptance criteria. Finally, 25 articles that met the inclusion criteria were studied. They were analyzed using three-step coding method (open, axial, selective). The reliability of the codings was confirmed using the kappa agreement coefficient in SPSS software with a value of 0.75 and to evaluate the validity of the study, the findings were provided to two qualitative research experts. Based on the results of data analysis, 129 open codes were identified, which were classified into 6 categories and 23 sub-categories, which include professional coaching competency (perceptual skills, communication skills, technical skills, knowledge And experience, personality and moral characteristics, professional credibility), cochee conditions and characteristics (desire and motivation, personal characteristics, commitment and responsibility, cognitive skills, knowledge and competency, organizational position), Coaching process (planning and organizing, evaluation methods), relationship quality (relationship level, cooperation and agreement, mutual respect and trust, professional learning), organizational context (support of top managers, organizational culture, structural And strategic factors) and external context (cultural factors, environmental factors). Manuscript profile -
Open Access Article
14 - Designing a coaching model for operational managers of Persian Gulf Petrochemical Company in order to motivate human resources
Hajat hajizadeh Foad Makvandi Ghanbar AmirnejadContemporary organizations operate in an increasingly complex and changing environment. Therefore, they are seeking a new approach in management and leadership to meet the needs of employees and organizations to thrive in today's highly dynamic environment. Coaching of MoreContemporary organizations operate in an increasingly complex and changing environment. Therefore, they are seeking a new approach in management and leadership to meet the needs of employees and organizations to thrive in today's highly dynamic environment. Coaching of managers is defined as a strategy for human resource development and is a dynamic process that improves job performance.The present study was aimed to design a coaching model for operational managers of the Persian Gulf Petrochemical Company for motivating human resources. The statistical population of the study included 18 experts of senior managers and human resource managers of the Persian Gulf Petrochemical Company, faculty, or university teachers. In this qualitative study, from the foundation data strategy and saturation sampling method was used and the interviews were coded using maxqda software. The results indicated that out of 805 extracted concepts, 145 basic codes were identified in 23 categories including communication, strategy, and objectives of the organization, legal requirements, human resource motivation, organizational training, empowerment, teamwork, succession planning, organizational agility, job satisfaction, organizational structure, human resource management performance, organizational culture, participatory management, talent management, knowledge management, coaching, skills, and competencies of managers, service compensation system, job characteristics, staff features, organizational characteristics, and learning. Manuscript profile -
Open Access Article
15 - The effect of organizational learning on organizational change with regard to the mediating role of staff professional development (Case study: Central Bank of the Islamic Republic of Iran)
Manijeh Ahmadi Samad BaraniOrganizational learning is the most important asset to facilitate the professional development of employees as well as organizational transformation. Purpose of the research; Investigating the effect of organizational learning on organizational change with regard to the MoreOrganizational learning is the most important asset to facilitate the professional development of employees as well as organizational transformation. Purpose of the research; Investigating the effect of organizational learning on organizational change with regard to the mediating role of professional development of employees in the Central Bank of the Islamic Republic of Iran. The research method is descriptive-applied and structural equations. Statistical population of all managers and management experts of high levels of the Central Bank and its affiliated organizations (429 people) from which 203 people were selected by simple random sampling. The standard questionnaire of organizational learning (Azizi; 2014), organizational transformation (John Gutter and Peter Drucker; 2005) and staff professional development (Long et al., 2015) were used to collect data. Its validity was assessed through face validity and reliability by Cronbach's alpha (organizational learning: 0.95, organizational transformation: 0.92, staff professional development: 0.88). Data were analyzed using SPSS and AMOS software. The results showed that organizational learning has a direct effect on staff professional development and organizational change and staff professional development has a significant mediating role in the relationship between organizational learning and organizational change. Manuscript profile -
Open Access Article
16 - Developing a Workplace Learning Framework for Chamber of Commerce based on a Grounded Theory Research
Farhad Fathi Marjan Kian Majid Ali AsgariThe aim of the present study was to develop a framework for workplace learning. The research paradigm was qualitative and the grounded theory research method was use. The research population consisted of all the employees and members of Chamber of Commerce. Then 18 inf MoreThe aim of the present study was to develop a framework for workplace learning. The research paradigm was qualitative and the grounded theory research method was use. The research population consisted of all the employees and members of Chamber of Commerce. Then 18 informants were selected by targeted sampling method until reaching the data saturation. The research tool was an in-depth semi-structured interview. In order to analyze the data, coding and categorization were used by Atlas ti software and in three stages of noticing, collecting and thinking. In order to evaluate the data strength in the present study, three criteria of "acceptability", "reliability" and "verifiability" were used. Based on the findings, the framework of the workplace learning consisted of the environment (equality and justice, working environment, learning culture and supportive work environment), the employees (interest in work and learning, responsibility and intelligence and discipline), the management (leadership power, scientific literacy And ethical virtues), the curriculum (goal setting and purposefulness, educational content, teachers 'ability, supervision and implementation, feedback and correction) and the interaction and integration (management-staff interaction, colleagues' interaction with each other, combination of formal and experimental education, integration). Outcomes of workplace learning include organizational efficiency and effectiveness, financial benefit, cohesiveness and expertise, career advancement along with employee motivation. Manuscript profile -
Open Access Article
17 - Identifying the strengths and weaknesses of e-learning courses in human resource education of the National Iranian Gas Company
Marziyeh Dehghani Farzane TariThe purpose of this study is to investigate Strengths and Weaknesses of E-Learning courses in human resources education of Iranian National Gas Company based on the systemic model of Hao and Borich. Parallel to this aim, a qualitative research design of the phenomenol MoreThe purpose of this study is to investigate Strengths and Weaknesses of E-Learning courses in human resources education of Iranian National Gas Company based on the systemic model of Hao and Borich. Parallel to this aim, a qualitative research design of the phenomenological type was selected. The statistical society of this research includes the managers and technicians of the headquarter section of the Iranian National Gas Company, out of which 10 people were selected by purposeful sampling. Then, the researcher attempted to collect data through semi-structured interviews to reach theoretical saturation. The data were then analyzed by the Collaizi’s seven-step method. Deep analysis of the interviews revealed 23 related categories and 86 sub-categories. Based on the findings of the study, the strengths of administering electronic education in the Iranian National Gas Company include learners’ satisfactionnd willingness, scientific expertise of professors, the support from organization’s managers, production of high-quality context, compiling a comprehensive collection of exam questions, having a good method of administration and good design of virtual exam administration processes. As for the weak points, the resulted items included unpreparedness and insufficient expertise of professors, weakness of network connections, incomprehensive outlook in compilation of purposes, domination of lecturing method in teaching of virtual courses, and untrustworthiness of the precision of virtual exams. In the end, reevaluation and provision of appropriate mechanisms to mitigate the effects of potential threats and promote positive situations is emphasized and a few applicable recommendations have been provided. Manuscript profile -
Open Access Article
18 - Designing and explaining the professional development model of the departments chairs of the University of Tehran based on a Lean approach
mojtaba hajkhozeymh Khodayar Abili javad pourkarimiPurpose: The main purpose of this study is to design and explain the professional development model of the departments chairs of the University of Tehran based on a Lean approach. Method: This research was carried out in two qualitative and quantitative stages, using MorePurpose: The main purpose of this study is to design and explain the professional development model of the departments chairs of the University of Tehran based on a Lean approach. Method: This research was carried out in two qualitative and quantitative stages, using the mixed exploratory research method. The qualitative part of the research was done in two stages. In the first stage of the qualitative section, the existing research background related to the components of professional development of department heads based on a lean approach in Persian and English between 2000 and 2020 was reviewed. After searching, screening and qualitative evaluation of the studies, the final synthesis was performed on 72 studies. In the second stage of the qualitative section, semi-structured interviews were conducted with 20 experts and experts in the field of higher education who were purposefully selected to identify the appropriate pattern of the context of the University of Tehran. Qualitative data analysis was performed using open and axial coding (theme analysis) and its reliability and validity were evaluated. In the quantitative stage, the descriptive-analytical research method and the statistical population included all the managers of the departments of the University of Tehran with 252 people who using Cochran's sampling formula, 152 people were selected as the sample. Sampling method in this study was stratified random sampling method. In the quantitative part, the required data were collected using a researcher-made questionnaire. To evaluate the validity of the quantitative research instrument, content validity and construct validity were used and to evaluate the reliability of the instrument, Cronbach's alpha was used, which confirmed the appropriate reliability and validity of the research instrument. Results: The results showed that the professional development of the managers of the departments of the University of Tehran based on a lean approach has five main components (1. Lean leadership / management skills, 2. Lean student skills, 3. Lean research skills, 4. Lean behavioral skills and 5. Skills Lean individual) and 19 indicators. The results of the second-order confirmatory factor analysis showed that the five identified components have a sufficient factor load to predict the professional development of department heads of the University of Tehran based on a lean approach. The results of one-sample t-test showed that the managers of the departments of the University of Tehran evaluated the general situation of their professional development based on a lean approach at a moderate level. Conclusion:The five main components of this research can be an effective model for the professional development of department heads in university of Tehran and have beneficial results in promoting quality, efficiency, effectiveness and waste reduction in university of Tehran. Manuscript profile -
Open Access Article
19 - Analysis of human resource development process and development of appropriate model in higher education system
Masumeh Oladian Maryam Golipour Mahmoud SafariThe purpose of this study was to analyze the process of human resource development and to develop an appropriate model in the higher education system and its method in a mixed way (qualitative and quantitative). The research community in the qualitative part consisted o MoreThe purpose of this study was to analyze the process of human resource development and to develop an appropriate model in the higher education system and its method in a mixed way (qualitative and quantitative). The research community in the qualitative part consisted of professors, specialists and experts in this field and in the quantitative part consisted of professors, experts, experts and managers of the higher education system. In the qualitative section, which was purposefully selected, 12 professors, specialists and experts were selected, and in the quantitative section, 382 experts and managers of the higher education system were selected using the Cochran's formula. The research tools were semi-structured interview and researcher-made questionnaire. Analysis of collected data, in the qualitative part by grounded theory method and through coding using MAXQDA software and in the quantitative part by descriptive and inferential methods using SPSS 16 software And Smart PLS was done. The results showed that twelve components are involved in explaining the human resource development process and developing an appropriate model in the higher education system, which are: Self-efficacy, self-esteem, motivation, empowerment, organizational learning, organizational culture, knowledge management, technology, job satisfaction, community development, facilitating networking, and ultimately human capital development. To check the fit of the model, check the X2, R and RS; It was discussed that the presence of low X2 and the ratio of chi-square to the degree of freedom less than three, as well as the coefficient of determination and the adjusted coefficient of determination were calculated; Indicates the proper fit of the model. Manuscript profile -
Open Access Article
20 - Barriers and Challenges of Managers Coaching Success in the Petrochemical Industry
Akbar Hassanpoor Yusuf Vakili Saeed Jaafari Nia Raha FarhadiThe purpose of the current study is to identify barriers and challenges of managers coaching success in the petrochemical industry for which mixed methodology is utilized. In the qualitative section, Clarke and Braun’s (2006) thematic analysis was used to extract the in MoreThe purpose of the current study is to identify barriers and challenges of managers coaching success in the petrochemical industry for which mixed methodology is utilized. In the qualitative section, Clarke and Braun’s (2006) thematic analysis was used to extract the indicators of such barriers; it means that by studying current studies in this regard, basic, organizing and pervasive barriers were coded. Ultimately, a 40 – item questionnaire was obtained by using thematic analysis while the third-order factor analysis with partial lease squares approach was utilized to test the questionnaire. The research population consists of 167 petrochemical managers, deputies, and heads of whom 116 were selected by using the Cochran formula and simple random sampling method while the SMART PLS software package was used to analyze data. The third-order factor analysis findings indicated weakness in communicative and problem-solving skills. Weakness in feedback providing skills, improper managerial style, lack of setting pragmatic goals and obliging to them, improper coach’s behavior and vision, coachee’s propensity to commanding style, lack of trust to coaches, lack of coachee’s motivation, improper organizational culture and unawareness, structural weakness and lack of senior managers’ support, improper HR supportive systems and lack of supports by natural culture can be seen as the barriers on managers coaching success in the petrochemical industry. Additionally, findings indicate that barriers related to coach (0.91), intra-organizational barriers (0.81), inter-organizational barriers (0.68) and barriers related to coachee (0.55) have the highest and lowest impact on managers coaching success respectively. The final result is that the barriers to managers coaching success-tested model enjoys proper validity and reliability and can be used in the petrochemical industry. Manuscript profile -
Open Access Article
21 - Providing a model of professional training for employees (Case study: Qeshm Azhend Company)
aliakbar jalilehvand parastoo khosravi Baharak Shirzad Kebria Parinaz BenisiOrganizations need capable employees to survive. In fact, the current competitive environment of organizations, need effective and efficient employees to be able to achieve their goals for growth and development. In this regard, the purpose of this study is to provide a MoreOrganizations need capable employees to survive. In fact, the current competitive environment of organizations, need effective and efficient employees to be able to achieve their goals for growth and development. In this regard, the purpose of this study is to provide a model of professional training of employees. In this study, in order to combine qualitative and quantitative data, a sequential integrated exploratory method was used, according to the classification model with emphasis on qualitative data. The statistical population in the qualitative section consisted of experts familiar with the subject of the research, which was conducted in a non-random and purposeful manner until the theoretical saturation of the 30 interview questionnaire. Also, in the quantitative part, the statistical population includes all employees of Qeshm Azhend Company (Panasonic), whose number is equal to 3122 people. The statistical sample in this research, using random sampling method and Cochran's formula, the sample size was 342 people. In this study, two questionnaires were used to collect the data needed to measure the variables under study, the validity of which was confirmed by the opinions of experts and the reliability of Cronbach's alpha. In order to analyze the data from the approach Grand theory and structural equations were used with MAXQDA, SPSS-PLS software. The results showed that the main dimensions of the model are organizational factors, managerial factors, individual factors and structural factors and include 74 sub-components and the results of the research model show Shows that the model used in the present study had a good fit. Manuscript profile -
Open Access Article
22 - Choosing the Most Desirable Manager Development Learning Methods Using TOPSIS Technique(Case study: National Iranian Oil Refining & Distribution Company (NIORDC)
Yasamin Javadi Mahdieh Asadi Hamidreza YazdaniThe present research was conducted to select desirable learning methods for managerial development based on effective criteria and dimensions using TOPSIS technique. Given the purpose, an applied method of research is used. To collect data, a survey descrip MoreThe present research was conducted to select desirable learning methods for managerial development based on effective criteria and dimensions using TOPSIS technique. Given the purpose, an applied method of research is used. To collect data, a survey descriptive method of research is used. The National Iranian Petroleum Refining and Distribution Company (NIORDC) was selected as the statistical population and 15 managers and experts in the field related to managers' learning and development were selected for interviews using purposive sampling. Data collection is performed using both library or documentary methods to review the literature and field study includes structured interviews, distribution and collection of the questioner. The validity of the questioner has been assessed and also approved by the experts due to its consistency with the literature. The reliability of the questioner has been approved by repeat testing. Best Worst method (BWM) as well as Expert choice software have been used for analyzing data and determining the coefficiency of influencing criteria of needs assessment methods and identification of their priorities. TOPSIS technique and Excel have been also used to determine Closeness Coefficient and the priority of each learning methods. Research Findings indicate that the game and simulation method is the most desirable learning method to implement the development programs of managers in the company. Manuscript profile -
Open Access Article
23 - Reviewing a systematic of the concept and theories of critical human resource development
hamed dehghanan Mahya MohammadiThe purpose of this article is to study the existing literature in the field of critical human resource development, which leads to the creation of a framework including concepts and theories related to this field. For this purpose, this research is written based on a s MoreThe purpose of this article is to study the existing literature in the field of critical human resource development, which leads to the creation of a framework including concepts and theories related to this field. For this purpose, this research is written based on a systematic review method on existing research in this field. First, a large number of articles entitled Human Resource Development (HRD) were selected from reputable databases such as SAGE, Emerald Insight, Google Scholar, ScienceDirect, and then articles with the keyword critical or perspectives were selected and the rest were removed. After studying the remaining articles, 6 articles with richer literature were selected for review. The results showed that the critical human resource development approach means that learning and development activities are pursued with sufficient awareness of power relations, emotions and organizational policy in the form of the concept of critical learning. Also theories related to this approach include theories of self and work, learning at work, and emotion. Finally, in order to implement critical human resource development, organizational contexts, stakeholders, methods and processes in each of the four areas involved in critical human resource development, including relating, learning, changing and organizing, should be examined. Manuscript profile -
Open Access Article
24 - Analysis and Identification of General and Specialized Competencies of Financial Expert with Development Approach (Case Study: Day Bank)
Mansoureh Chahardoli Zahra Lebady Fatemeh Parasteh-Ghombavani Mojgan AbdollahiFinancial experts have a key role in the informed decision-making of managers in the strategic plans of banks, therefore, the performance of this group of experts is particularly sensitive. With this in mind, this article identifies the competencies of financial experts MoreFinancial experts have a key role in the informed decision-making of managers in the strategic plans of banks, therefore, the performance of this group of experts is particularly sensitive. With this in mind, this article identifies the competencies of financial experts in the field of banking. According to the nature and purpose of this research, its approach is qualitative and has been done with the method of Grounded Theory and Charms structuralist design. The statistical population of the research includes all financial experts working in the financial department of Bank Day Total: liquidity management and management accounting). Research tools include semi-structured interviews, notebooks and tape recorders. The data of this study are the result of interviews with 30 financial experts who were selected by snowball sampling method (sampling was continued until the theoretical saturation stage in the collected information). The text of the interviews, which included 33 hours of individual interviews with the research sample, was Implemented and analyzed by theme analysis method. A total of 79 competencies were identified as required competencies for Bank Day financial experts in the form of 12 sub-categories and 4 main categories with individual, interpersonal, basic and general knowledge titles. Job, technical and key job knowledge and finally in two dimensions of specialized and general competencies were determined and defined. Manuscript profile -
Open Access Article
25 - Design and Validation of Strategic Training Model to develop Human Resources in the Automotive Industry (Case study: Saipa Automotive Group)
Mohamad ali Borjikhani avanaki Esmat Masoudy Nadoshan Zahara Taleb Naiereh ShahmohammadyThe present study was conducted to design a strategic training model and explain its role in human resource development. This research is applied research that has used the mixed exploratory method as the research method. The community of participants in the quality sec MoreThe present study was conducted to design a strategic training model and explain its role in human resource development. This research is applied research that has used the mixed exploratory method as the research method. The community of participants in the quality section of 27 people and a small number of 400 experts in the field of training and development of human resources and strategy of Saipa Automotive Group has been used as a participant. Purposeful sampling method was used in qualitative and stratified random section in the quantitative section. Data collection tools in the qualitative part included semi-structured interviews and in the quantitative part included a researcher-made questionnaire. Excel data were used for data analysis in the qualitative part and AMOS and 19SPSS software were used for the quantitative part. Data analysis method In the qualitative part, including the basic data method(Grounded Theory) (open, axial and selective coding) in the quantitative part, the method of path analysis, Pearson correlation and factor analysis have been used. The results of this research in the qualitative part led to the formation of a strategic training model to develop human resources in Saipa Automotive Group and in a quantitative part, the impact of the strategic training model in explaining human resource development was investigated. The results show that strategic training has a direct and significant effect on factors such as personal development and empowerment, knowledge sharing and improving individual performance and employee well-being. These results confirm the compliance of this study with previous research. The findings of this study can provide practical and operational tools for the development of human resources in the Saipa Automotive Group. Manuscript profile -
Open Access Article
26 - investigating the feasibility of establishing the workplace curriculum in Iranian universities
zahra pourjafarian koroush fathi vajargah Saeed Safaei Movahed maryam Hoseini LorganiAbstract The present research aims at investigating the feasibility of establishing the workplace curriculum in Iranian universities. This research seeks to answer the following question: Is it possible to establish the workplace curriculum field at the Iranian univers MoreAbstract The present research aims at investigating the feasibility of establishing the workplace curriculum in Iranian universities. This research seeks to answer the following question: Is it possible to establish the workplace curriculum field at the Iranian universities to train specialists in this field? The present study is qualitative research in terms of the purpose, nature, and implementation facilities. Semi-structured interviews with ten workplace curriculum specialists were used to conduct the research. Since this research focuses on the workplace curriculum, the critical case sampling method was used in this research. The information of the interviews was analyzed using the content analysis method. Based on the findings, the opinions of workplace curriculum specialists were categorized into three groups of proponents, conditional proponents, and opponents of establishing this field. Then, the roles and capabilities of the workplace curriculum graduates and their expected competencies were identified. Based on the finding of the research,the opinion of the education specialists in response to the necessity of establishing a field at university are divided into three thematic categories as "factors related to the field of curriculum studies", "factors related to similar fields and university majors" and "factors related to the workplace".Then, by analyzing the content of the experts' opinion in response to the topic of "preconditions necessary for the establishment of university field", two thematic categories of "executive conditions", "scientific conditions" and sub-themes were introduced. At the end, the roles , abilities and competencies of the graduates were examined. Manuscript profile -
Open Access Article
27 - Designing a Model of Training Managers for Future
Hoda Jajarmi Ali Asghar Pourezzat Kamal DorraniThis research focuses on the need to develop meaningful training programs as a part of the reform of the secondary education system. Given that preparing the future managers is a responsibility we all share today, this study aims at designing a model for training future MoreThis research focuses on the need to develop meaningful training programs as a part of the reform of the secondary education system. Given that preparing the future managers is a responsibility we all share today, this study aims at designing a model for training future managers. This study adopted a qualitative exploratory approach. Accordingly, subsequent to reviewing the related literature, the semi-structured interviews with 15 selected senior managers in the Ministry of Education as well as experts and elites of the field were done. Participants were selected based on the snowball method. The interviews continued until the saturation level was achieved. Then, interviews were analyzed using the thematic analysis method. After analyzing the data and extracting the codes, they were classified into three major categories: 47 basic concepts, 18 organizers, and 5 inclusive themes, as the components of the model. The five inclusive themes were named as self-management, social factors, management of others, planning and the education system policy, and educational skills. Then, the model was designed based on the relationships among the themes. Finally, the research findings suggested that teaching management skills to adolescents, based on the recommended model of secondary school education system transformation, would lead to changes in the educational policy and development of such management skills as communication skills, critical thinking, leadership, and teamwork. At the end, recommendations are made based on the sub-themes obtained in each area and the key points raised by the experts of the field. Manuscript profile -
Open Access Article
28 - Presenting an International Model of Manpower Training in the Ministry of Health and Medical Education
Aram Ghaniuon Ali Reza Afsharnejad Zeinolabedin Amini Sabegh Ehsan SadehThe aim of this study is to provide a model for the internationalization of human resources training in the Ministry of Health and Medical Education. The research is qualitative and grounded theory method has been used to analyze the data. For this purpose, in-depth int MoreThe aim of this study is to provide a model for the internationalization of human resources training in the Ministry of Health and Medical Education. The research is qualitative and grounded theory method has been used to analyze the data. For this purpose, in-depth interviews were conducted with 15 people who are experts in the field of internationalization of manpower training, using the method of snowball sampling. The data obtained from the interviews were then analyzed through open, axial and selective coding. At the end, a paradigm model of internationalization of human resources training consisting of causal conditions, contextual conditions, intervening conditions, pivotal phenomena, strategies and consequences was drawn. The main phenomenon of the designed model is the internationalization of human resources training in the Ministry of Health and Medical Education. Findings showed that causal factors include infrastructure, necessary standards, available facilities and internationalization needs. Interfering factors include the political situation in the country, educational and academic centers, environmental factors, managerial integrity and executive factors. Underlying factors include the competitive environment and attitudes towards the phenomenon of globalization and strategies in the form of culture, creating an appropriate scientific and research structure, effective propaganda, social programs and laws and regulations. The implications of an international system of manpower training also include cultural, economic, communicative, and educational achievements. Manuscript profile -
Open Access Article
29 - Review the gap between the existing and desired performance of the employees in order to implementation of the human performance improvement in the social security organization
SHERVIN MASHAYEKHI Mohammad salehi TARANEH ENAYATIperformance analysis in organizations and identifying the gap of performance , its causes and roots is very important which can improve the quality of services of organizations , customer satisfaction and services . therefore , this study aims to identify the dimensions Moreperformance analysis in organizations and identifying the gap of performance , its causes and roots is very important which can improve the quality of services of organizations , customer satisfaction and services . therefore , this study aims to identify the dimensions of employee performance gap in order to deploy human performance improvement in social security organization . this research has been done in terms of purpose among applied research and qualitative method . the statistical sample of this research includes 120 experts ( academic and organizational ) and data collection tool is taking notes from texts , theoretical studies and available models . the results indicate that performance gap can be divided into three aspects : leadership style , workplace and human resource management . based on the findings in the first dimension , components of strategic management , structure , processes , style of management and interests of stakeholders , in the second dimension , components of organizational culture , environmental conditions , data and information and finally in the third dimension , components of human resource management , individual competencies , service system and compensation were confirmed . furthermore , by confirming the final model of performance gap , the stages of human performance improvement were identified in five stages . Manuscript profile -
Open Access Article
30 - Providing a Model of Workforce Development and Agility Using a Mixed Method of Meta-Analysis and Fuzzy DEMATEL in Maskan Bank of Iran
Ali Aali Mohammad Zia Al Dini mostafa hadavinejadThe aim of this research is to identify the antecedents and components of workforce development and agility and also to offer a mixed model of meta-analysis and Fuzzy DEMATEL method in Maskan Bank. Workforce agility development antecedents of quantitative studies were e MoreThe aim of this research is to identify the antecedents and components of workforce development and agility and also to offer a mixed model of meta-analysis and Fuzzy DEMATEL method in Maskan Bank. Workforce agility development antecedents of quantitative studies were extracted by Meta –Analysis. Then the effect size of antecedents (consequent of components) was calculated by CMA3 software. 3 out of 19 identified antecedents, were obtained with the effect size equal or greater than 0.5. The 3 antecedents include the intertwinement and the relationship between training and the system of recruitment and employment, the use of experts in training and development, and the pay and reward system. Afterwards the first questionnaire was given to experts for reviewing and screening the qualitative components as well as the components of interview. In the last phase acquired components of 3 antecedents with others acquired components of the first questionnaire were sent to experts via the second questionnaire. According to this, 4 components including "organizational intelligence", "low formalization," “perceptual skills” and "creative problem solving" had the most impact on other components. Components of “promptitude”, “organizational commitment”, “accountability” and “flexibility”, were the most influential components identified. In terms of the importance, “Adaptability” was identified as the most important component and “proactivity” was identified as the least important one. Manuscript profile -
Open Access Article
31 - Identifying The Faculty Development Based On Entrepreneurship (Case study: Payame Noor University, Hormozgan Province)
Yusef Mahmoodi khamiripoor Nadergholi GHourchian mohamadnoor rahmaniFaculty development based on entrepreneurship can lead to the evolution and promotion of educational and research areas in according to entrepreneurial goals, and then it can be expected that the output of these developments, researchers and innovative students, whic MoreFaculty development based on entrepreneurship can lead to the evolution and promotion of educational and research areas in according to entrepreneurial goals, and then it can be expected that the output of these developments, researchers and innovative students, which defines the power, the problem. And provide creative solutions for business and industry goals and continuous quality development in various activities and missions of the university. Faculty development based on entrepreneurship approach is an attempt by the academic system to reform the knowledge, attitude and skills of professors in the form of training, retraining, study opportunities, scholarships and in according to entrepreneurial goals. To succeed in advancing the process of Faculty development based on entrepreneurship to optimal policy, a set of key factors should be identified. In this article, the researcher uses the analysis of the theme to identify the factors affecting the Faculty development based on entrepreneurship at the University of Hormozgan province. For this purpose, with interviews conducted with expert people in this field.71 basic themes, along with 25 organized themes, were identified based on the deduction of the researcher in 5 inclusive dimensions including individual development, organizational development, Educational development and professional development were categorized and eventually resulted in scientific and operational suggestions. Manuscript profile -
Open Access Article
32 - Comparison of the three levels of Electronic Performance Support System (EPSS) on improving performance and increasing employee efficiency (Case study: Day Insurance employees)
Marjan zahedian Hashem Fardanesh Javad Hatami kiumars taghipourThe purpose of this study was to measure the effectiveness of the three types of electronic performance support systems (Intrinsic, Extrinsic, and External) on employee performance improvement. The statistical population in this research was 750 insurance agents of the MoreThe purpose of this study was to measure the effectiveness of the three types of electronic performance support systems (Intrinsic, Extrinsic, and External) on employee performance improvement. The statistical population in this research was 750 insurance agents of the Day insurance. The cluster sampling method was used to select 90 participants. These participants were divided randomly into three groups: Intrinsic and Extrinsic, and External Performance Support Systems. To assess the performance of the participants, we used questionnaires, and for efficiency, insurance agent's arrival, and departure time to the electronic environment were estimated. The collected data was analyzed using MANOVA. The results of the data analysis showed that the insurance agents who participated in the Intrinsic and Extrinsic Performance Support Systems had better performance. In addition, Intrinsic Performance Support Systems participants have been able to perform their job responsibilities in a shorter time than insurance agents of the other two groups. Manuscript profile -
Open Access Article
33 - The Interrelationship between Psychological Empowerment, Employees' Spiritual Intelligence and Reducing Occupational Accidents (Case Study: National Iranian Copper Industries Company)
sasan Taghizadeh Alireza Manzari Tavakoli Sanjar Salajegheh samaneh mehdizadehThis study aimed to explain the interrelationships between psychological empowerment, employees' spiritual intelligence and reducing occupational accidents. The present study follows a three-step process. For this purpose, in the first step, by taking advantage of docum MoreThis study aimed to explain the interrelationships between psychological empowerment, employees' spiritual intelligence and reducing occupational accidents. The present study follows a three-step process. For this purpose, in the first step, by taking advantage of documentary based research and library research method, the existing and available scientific literature were reviewed to count the factors affecting the dimensions of the research. Then, the fuzzy Delphi method was used to finalize and localize the factors affecting the three dimensions. Finally, DEMATEL-based ANP (DANP) technique was used to determine the relationships between the main and secondary variables and how they interact with each other (interaction). The final statistical population of this study consisted of 11 experts in the field of organizational behavior and senior managers of safety, accidents and control of the National Iranian Copper Industries Company. The judgmental sampling was used select the sample, which is an nonprobability method. The results showed that psychological empowerment and employees' spiritual intelligence directly and unilaterally affect the reduction of occupational accidents, and this means that the promotion and improvement of psychological empowerment and employees' spiritual intelligence reduces the occupational accidents. Also, it was found that there is a two-way relationship between psychological empowerment and employees' spiritual intelligence. Manuscript profile -
Open Access Article
34 - Identify the Prerequisites for Implementation a Formal Mentoring Program in the Organization
Mahnaz Akbari Ebrahim Rajabpour Aryan gholipourGiven the importance and necessity of mentoring, as one of the methods of human resource development in Iranian organizations and the fact that the successful implementation of formal mentoring requires a proper platform and the necessary maturity in the organization. T MoreGiven the importance and necessity of mentoring, as one of the methods of human resource development in Iranian organizations and the fact that the successful implementation of formal mentoring requires a proper platform and the necessary maturity in the organization. Therefore, the purpose of this study is to identify the prerequisites for the successful implementation of the formal mentoring program. The statistical population of the research is university professors and experts familiar with human resource development and especially mentoring method. The research method is qualitative and based on the paradigm of interpretiveness. To achieve this, after reviewing the mentoring literature community, interview questions were designed and after confirming the validity of the questions, 15 people with expertise in the field of human resource development, especially mentoring, were interviewed by purposive sampling. Then, the results of the interviews were analyzed using the theme analysis method using Brown and Clark approach and the necessary prerequisites for mentoring were categorized in the form of McKenzie 7S model. The results showed that factors such as; a culture based on learning, the maturity of human resource processes, the financial strength of the organization and the existence of a strategic vision in the organization are the main prerequisites for implementing a formal mentoring program in the organization. Manuscript profile -
Open Access Article
35 - Designing of an entrepreneurial educational model in the automotive industry: Iran khodro diesel
arzhang ezatinia sayed rassul hosseini Masome OladianThis research has been organized with the aim of designing an entrepreneurial educational model in the automotive industry, which is a mixed research (quantitative and qualitative) in terms of purpose, application and in terms of how to collect information. The statisti MoreThis research has been organized with the aim of designing an entrepreneurial educational model in the automotive industry, which is a mixed research (quantitative and qualitative) in terms of purpose, application and in terms of how to collect information. The statistical population in the qualitative section includes academic and organizational experts including industrial experts such as education supervisors training liaisons, training instructors, thematic experts in the company such as welding experts and in the quantitative part includes all Iran Khodro Diesel automotive training staff . The sample size in the qualitative part with theoretical saturation (20 people) was estimated using purposive sampling and in the quantitative part based on Cochran's formula 127 people was estimated by stratified random sampling.was confirmed by calculating the trough and the validity of the questionnaire was confirmed by calculating the square root of the AVE. The reliability of the questionnaire was obtained through Cronbach's alpha for the whole questionnaire of 0.968. Lisrel and smartpls3 software were used to analyze the data. The results identified 23 components and 133 indicators that learners 'personal characteristics (0.173), teachers' personal characteristics (0.171), educational content (0.169), industry-university interaction (0.167), teaching methods (0.157), support Senior manager (0.156), leadership and management style (0.143), space and educational equipment (0.124) according to their factor load, respectively, components have an impact on entrepreneurial education. Outcomes include commitment (0.745), satisfaction (0.670), employee self-efficacy (0.655), innovation (0.647), employee empowerment (0636), performance (0.603), and organizational agility (0.568), respectively. The proposed model had a good degree of fit Manuscript profile -
Open Access Article
36 - Presenting a model for attracting human resources with a human resources development approach in government organizations (Case study: Khorasan Razavi province)
Saeed Keramati Tavalllaei habibolah doaei Abolfazl KazemiThis article aims to provide a model of human resource absorption with the development of human resources in government organizations. In terms of purpose, the present study is an applied-developmental research and in terms of data collection method, it is a cross-secti MoreThis article aims to provide a model of human resource absorption with the development of human resources in government organizations. In terms of purpose, the present study is an applied-developmental research and in terms of data collection method, it is a cross-sectional research. To achieve the research goal, a mixed exploratory design has been used. The statistical population in the qualitative section includes managers of government organizations in Khorasan Razavi province. Purposeful sampling was performed and 15 people achieved theoretical love. The statistical population also includes 6000 human resources of government organizations, which with the Cochran's formula is estimated at a sample size of 345 people. The required sample size was provided by stratigraphic sampling method in four regions of Khorasan Razavi province. Interviews and questionnaires were used to collect data. The basic categories of human resource development were identified by content analysis method and the final model was identified by validation equation modeling method. Qualitative data analysis was performed with Maxqda software and quantitative data with LISREL. The results of comprehensive categories are categorized in terms of technical, human and value factors. Organizing factors also include skill, knowledge, attitude, behavior, adherence to values, pragmatism, economic, technological, social, cultural, revolutionary, powerful. Technical factors consist of knowledge, skills, economic factors and technology. Human factors include attitudes, behaviors, social and cultural factors. Finally, value factors include adherence to values, pragmatism, revolutionary factors, and authority. Manuscript profile -
Open Access Article
37 - Presenting a model for human resource development in Shiraz Municipality using a mixed exploration plan
Masoud paydariThis article aims to provide a model for human resource development in Shiraz Municipality. In terms of purpose, it is an applied-developmental research and in terms of data collection method, a cross-sectional research. To achieve the research goal, a mixed exploratory MoreThis article aims to provide a model for human resource development in Shiraz Municipality. In terms of purpose, it is an applied-developmental research and in terms of data collection method, a cross-sectional research. To achieve the research goal, a mixed exploratory design has been used. The statistical population in the qualitative section includes human resources professors and managers with a history of Shiraz Municipality. Purposeful sampling was performed and 15 subjects achieved theoretical saturation. The statistical population of the quantitative section also includes 3400 employees of Shiraz Municipality, which with the Cochran's formula, the sample size was estimated at 345 people. The required sample size was provided by stratified sampling method in four regions of Shiraz. Interviews and questionnaires were used to collect data. The basic categories of human resource development were identified by content analysis method and the final model was validated by partial least squares method. Qualitative data analysis was performed with Maxqda software and quantitative data with Smart PLS. The results show that inclusive categories are categorized in terms of strategic, educational, and growth factors. Strategic marketing factors are organizational factors that form the underlying elements of the model. Organizational categories of strategic factors include human resource management strategy and employee performance management. Organizing categories of educational factors also include organizational needs assessment, human resource needs assessment, and human resource training. Organizational categories related to growth and development also include the development of staff careers and the perceptual development of staff and the improvement of human resources. Manuscript profile -
Open Access Article
38 - Designing a Curriculum Model for the Development of Elementary School Teachers of the Iran's Educational System
mohsen abdolahi Mahbubeh Arefi KOUROSH FATHI VAJARGAH Abasalt KhorasaniThe main purpose of this study was to design a Curriculum Model for the Development of Elementary School Teachers of the Iran's Educational System. This study used a qualitative research approach and was conducted based on the classical grounded theory. The statistical MoreThe main purpose of this study was to design a Curriculum Model for the Development of Elementary School Teachers of the Iran's Educational System. This study used a qualitative research approach and was conducted based on the classical grounded theory. The statistical population consisted of Faculty members and experts in the field of Teachers development that was selected through snowball sampling. A total of 21 people, including 14 Faculty Members and 7 Teachers development specialists, were interviewed. Semi-structured interviews were used to collect data. The data from interviews were analyzed during three stages of open, selective and theoretical coding, and the conceptual model was formed based on the drawing of the ratio between the main categories or elements of the Teachers development curriculum. The conceptual model was formed as follows: causes and necessity (achieving the goals of the educational system, updating teacher skills, complex and flexible teacher role, reform, teacher growth and improving student learning), principles and conditions (teacher-centered, continuity and Sustainability, school-centered and job-oriented, content-oriented and based on student needs), components (content, context and process), correlated factors (personal, environmental, importance and priority, quantity, quality and time) and outcomes (teachers, Programs and students). To ensure validity and reliability, Guba and Lincoln approaches were used, including: acceptability, transferability, reliability and verifiability. Finally, based on the findings and results, guidelines for the implementation of the program are provided. Manuscript profile -
Open Access Article
39 - Identifying indicators of managerial competency in different companies of Tehran Municipality
fatemeh javadifard Alireza Amirkabiri mahmood dehganObjective: The importance and necessity of the present research can be examined in both theoretical and practical dimensions. Theoretically, considering that no research has been done in the field of designing and explaining the competency model of managers in different MoreObjective: The importance and necessity of the present research can be examined in both theoretical and practical dimensions. Theoretically, considering that no research has been done in the field of designing and explaining the competency model of managers in different companies in Tehran Municipality, this research can identify the concept of competence, dimensions as much as possible to fill the theoretical gap in the field of competence in Tehran Municipality. , Indicators and how to expand and improve and improve it more accurately and operationally and lead to an integrated and coherent model. From a practical point of view, this research can also play an effective role in improving their performance and ultimately improving the performance of the organization by determining the current status of managers in different companies of the organization Also, not studying the subject causes the managers in different companies to have an incomplete and incorrect view of the subject based on their different tastes and personal perceptions. Method: The type of research is applied in terms of purpose, expansion and improvement, and in terms of how it is collected, and it is combined in terms of data type. The statistical population of the study in the qualitative part consisted of 15 experts who were selected by non-probabilistic judgmental and purposeful sampling method and in the quantitative part included all managers in different companies of Tehran Municipality and the sample size was 384 people by method Simple random sampling was selected. Manuscript profile -
Open Access Article
40 - Designing and validating the growth model of faculty members
Mohammad bakhtiyari fereshteh kordestani lotfollah abbasi Abbas KhorshidiThis study was conducted to present the growth pattern of faculty members. The method of the present research in terms of practical objectives, In terms of data, it was an exploratory mix and in terms of nature and type of study, it was a cross-sectional survey. Researc MoreThis study was conducted to present the growth pattern of faculty members. The method of the present research in terms of practical objectives, In terms of data, it was an exploratory mix and in terms of nature and type of study, it was a cross-sectional survey. Research model based on studies Previously, inside and outside the country and the views of experts in this field were suggested. The statistical population of this research in the qualitative section 15 experts in the field of higher education and in a small dimension the faculty members of the Islamic Azad University, Tehran Branch Were central, and a sample of 280 of them identified by Morgan’s table. The main collection tool The data were first interviews with experts in this field and then the compilation of a seven-point questionnaire. Validity of measurement tools (CVR) and its validity was assessed and confirmed by Cronbach’s alpha. Pattern based on data analysis Optimally presented that has three dimensions: 1) Scientific abilities with a validity of %91 with three components of educational maturity, maturity Research, specialized maturity, 2) Personal abilities with a validity of %89 with two components: individual maturity, maturity Organizational 3) Spiritual / social abilities with a validity of %90 with two components of religious maturity and social maturity A total of 138 indicators had an effect on the growth of faculty members. This template can help managers and other professors Be a university. Manuscript profile -
Open Access Article
41 - Designing and presenting a model for human resource development with a succession approach in universities (Case study: Universities in Region 9 of the country)
hadi keikhosravi Farshad Faezi Razi Seyed Abdollah heydariyehHuman resource development is one of the important tasks or in other words the most important task of human resource management in organizations, which plays a vital role in the survival of organizations by focusing on training and helping the development of employees. MoreHuman resource development is one of the important tasks or in other words the most important task of human resource management in organizations, which plays a vital role in the survival of organizations by focusing on training and helping the development of employees. One of the best ways to develop employees and the organization is to use the succession system in the career development of employees, which will have numerous benefits for both the employee and the organization. This research has been done with the aim of designing and presenting a model of human resource development with a succession approach in universities.The research is based on data theory and is descriptive and exploratory in nature and method, and data collection is qualitative and based. It is based on semi-structured and purposeful interviews. The data required for this study were obtained by interviewing 14 university administrators in the country who had experience or expertise in the field of human resource management. Data analysis was performed using SPSS and Atlas.ti software in three stages of open coding, axial coding and selective coding inspired by the systematic paradigm model of Strauss and Corbin and the validity and reliability of the data using participants' review methods. And review obtained by experts. The central phenomenon of the present study is the development of employees based on the system of succession planning "which according to the causal, contextual, intervening conditions and its consequences, strategies have been formulated and the final model has been presented. Manuscript profile -
Open Access Article
42 - Investigating the Impact of Green Human Resources Development on Sustainable Production in Manufacturing Companies (Case Study: Shiraz Industrial Town)
Mohammad Saeed Mozafari MehrGreen human resource development is a new approach to job design that is based on employee innovation and if it is done based on economic, social and environmental goals, it can ultimately lead to sustainable production. Due to the importance and scope of the subject MoreGreen human resource development is a new approach to job design that is based on employee innovation and if it is done based on economic, social and environmental goals, it can ultimately lead to sustainable production. Due to the importance and scope of the subject of this study, the purpose of this study was to investigate the impact of green human resource development on sustainable production in manufacturing companies. The present study is a cross-sectional research in terms of exploratory purpose and method and time period of data collection. The statistical population in the qualitative part includes 19 experts in the field of human resource development and active managers of Shiraz Industrial Park and in the quantitative part includes the staff of Shiraz Industrial Park. The sample size was estimated to be 212 people using Morgan table and sampling was done by simple random method. The data collection tool was a semi-structured interview and a questionnaire that was validated by structural validity, convergent validity and divergent validity. Using Cronbach's alpha and combined reliability, the reliability of the questionnaire was as desirable. The partial least squares method and Smart PLS software were used to validate the green HR development model. Based on the results, it was found that the development of green human resources affects green self-efficacy, green behavior of employees and green citizenship behavior. Green behavior of employees as an important factor in this regard also affects green citizenship behavior and self-efficacy and affects sustainable production. Manuscript profile -
Open Access Article
43 - Designing a core competency model for Iranian gas industry managers based on the results of EFQM by artificial intelligence method
Ali reza Zamanian Majid Jahangirfard Farshad Haj alianThe success of organizations in achieving strategic goals is highly dependent on how the managers of that organization perform, and this success is more directly related to the selection and appointment of competent and knowledgeable managers at the top of the organizat MoreThe success of organizations in achieving strategic goals is highly dependent on how the managers of that organization perform, and this success is more directly related to the selection and appointment of competent and knowledgeable managers at the top of the organizational pyramid. Competency-based management is a strong approach to developing and maintaining the organization's human capital in the long run, and competency models are a useful tool for identifying and developing the knowledge, skills and abilities needed by managers. In general, competency is a set of knowledge, skills, attitudes, abilities, interests and personality traits that enable employees to perform job-related activities effectively and perform job performance as expected or beyond expectations. Do." In accordance with the competencies defined in the evaluation center of the managers of the National Iranian Gas Company and according to the nature of trainable competencies, three categories of communication competencies, managerial and leadership competencies, cognitive and one category of untrained personality competencies have been defined. In this article, we have tried to achieve a set of core competencies in the field of competencies of gas industry managers, which has been achieved based on the performance of managers in organizational excellence. These core competencies are the beacon of the organization in achieving strategic goals and can be purposefully effective in the shortest time and with the least cost in the development process of the managers of the organization. Manuscript profile -
Open Access Article
44 - Introducing Mentoring Model By Improving Human Resources Practices Approach, (Case Study: National Iranian South Oilfields Company)
Ali Ghasemi Ghasemvand Vahid Chenari Mehrdad Hamrahi aliakbar ahmadiThe purpose of this research is introducing mentoring model by improving Human Resources Practices approach in National Iranian South Oilfields Company. This research is done according to qualitative and quantitative approach (Mixed method). In qualitative step finding MoreThe purpose of this research is introducing mentoring model by improving Human Resources Practices approach in National Iranian South Oilfields Company. This research is done according to qualitative and quantitative approach (Mixed method). In qualitative step finding necessary factors and bases for model were done by use of interview with 11 people of experts that were chosen by use of snowball sampling method and theme analysis was used and this research is an exploratory research. To survey the validation of the research qualitative data gathering tool expert`s opinions were used and to survey the reliability of the theme analysis findings Kappa Index was used and 96 initial codes in the form of 12 themes and in fact necessary bases for designing model were found that consists of: organizational relationships, mentoring assessment, organizational education, organizational commitment, personnel empowerment, organizational chart, organizational factors, knowledge management, career path management, human resources management, organizational performance results and mentor`s individual characteristics. In quantitative step for model validation Structural Equations were used. In this research by use of stratified random sampling and according to Cochran formula, out of 105 people in the statistical population, the number of sample should be 83 people that 100 questionnaires were distributed for precaution. Research model according to qualitative analysis findings and results of Structural Equations and according to finding necessary bases for implementation of mentoring and by use of Partial Minimum Square Technique was examined and finally mentoring model by improving Haman Resource Practices Approach and suggestions for creating the necessary conditions and context for the implementation of mentoring were introduced. Manuscript profile -
Open Access Article
45 - Providing an e-learning pattern for Tejarat Bank managers
Seyede zahra sadat Kiyaei fatemeh hamidi far baharak shirzad kebriaThe purpose of this research is to provide an e-learning pattern for Tejarat Bank managers. This research is qualitative and quantitative (exploratory mix) in terms of applied purpose, in terms of how to collect data. The sample size in the qualitative to theoretical sa MoreThe purpose of this research is to provide an e-learning pattern for Tejarat Bank managers. This research is qualitative and quantitative (exploratory mix) in terms of applied purpose, in terms of how to collect data. The sample size in the qualitative to theoretical saturation section was 21 people and in the quantitative section according to Morgan table from the 300 managers of Tejarat Bank headquarters in the five districts of Tehran, 169 people were selected and distributed by stratified random sampling questionnaire. The researcher-made questionnaire in the form of 6 dimensions of paradigm model consisted of 19 components and 147 indicators. In order to identify and confirm the measurement factors, the validity of the questionnaire was tested separately for each dimension by first-order confirmation factor analysis (dimensions consisting of two components) and second-order (dimensions consisting of more than two components). The results show that confirmatory factor analysis confirmed the quantitative results of the Strauss and Corbin Foundation data model to a large extent and the e-learning model of Tejarat Bank managers with 6 dimensions, 19 components and 134 indicators was obtained. Including cultural readiness, technical readiness, educational readiness, environmental readiness; Causal factors include human factors, educational structure and policies, management; Interfering factors include individual approaches, managerial approaches; Strategies included educational approaches, pedagogical and andragogical approaches, educational assessment and evaluation, ease of access, targeted educational quality, innovation and creativity, integrated management and finally the consequences included educational success and meritocracy, foresight, increasing effectiveness and improving organizational performance. Manuscript profile -
Open Access Article
46 - Determining the factors of the decision making model for choosing training and learning methods in human resources development
Dr Firouz Nouri KalkhoranProviding an operational guide for the selection and implementation of learning methods in organizations as one of the tools used by managers and training professionals has a significant impact in effective knowledge transfer and optimal improvement of educational proce MoreProviding an operational guide for the selection and implementation of learning methods in organizations as one of the tools used by managers and training professionals has a significant impact in effective knowledge transfer and optimal improvement of educational processes. The theoretical model gap in this area and the increasing demand of organizations for decision-making are the main motivations for the author's research. For its theoretical model, this mixed research employed a theoretical research method in the qualitative section and a survey method in the quantitative section. In the qualitative section, after purposeful selection of experts from among managers and training professionals (using a snowball sampling method), the main factors influencing decision-making models were determined using a semi-structured approach. The participants in this section included twelve experts, and the results of the qualitative research section were extracted using thematic analysis. For the quantitative section, the validity of the questions was first confirmed by experts using the CVR method. Following the distribution and collection of questionnaires, they were analyzed using the Kolmogorov-Smirnov test, T-test, and central indices. Afterwards, the influential factors in determining training methods and human resource development were identified. Analytical Hierarchy Process (AHP) and Expert Choice software were used for weighting these factors. The influential factors, after identification with their weight coefficients, include Audience Level (0.161), Competency Development Program Scope (0.162), Competency Coverage Level (0.139), Competency Development Objective (0.044), Cost Allocation for Competency Development (0.284), Desired Competency Development Duration (0.067), Feasibility of Learner's Real Experience with Competency Phenomena (0.076), and Desired Learning Transfer Duration (0.064). To make the findings practical and direct their practical application, the results were presented in the form of fully functional decision-making software that aims to empower the organization in decision-making. Manuscript profile -
Open Access Article
47 - Designing and Validating Dynamic Computer-Based Scaffolding Model in Virtual In-Service Teacher Training
Zeynab Rashidi mohammadreza nili Esmaeil Zaraii Ali DelavarIn virtual in-service teacher training, instructional support or scaffolding is an essential component of effective training that can be provided in the form of computer-based scaffolding. Personalization of computer-based scaffolding is achieved with dynamic computer-b MoreIn virtual in-service teacher training, instructional support or scaffolding is an essential component of effective training that can be provided in the form of computer-based scaffolding. Personalization of computer-based scaffolding is achieved with dynamic computer-based scaffolding. The purpose of this study is to design and validate a model of dynamic computer-based scaffolding in virtual in-service teacher training. The research method used in this research was mixed method with sequential exploratory design. In qualitative research, the synthesis research method was used and the components of the model were extracted and a concept and process model was designed. Quantitative research was used to validate the model and survey research method and questionnaire were used and the internal validity of the proposed model was confirmed. Dynamic computer-based scaffolding model in virtual in-service teacher training has 8 main components and 47 sub-components. Key components include analysis with 11 subcomponents, design with 16 subcomponents, development with 3 subcomponents, implementation with 3 subcomponents, evaluation with 8 subcomponents, dissermination with 3 subcomponents, process evaluation and revision, and review and revision with 3 subcomponents. Internal validaty findings from experts showed that concept and process model have a high internal validity. Dynamic computer-based scaffolding model in online in-service teacher training can be used to design dynamic and computer-based instructional support and lead to learning and independent performance in the future. Manuscript profile -
Open Access Article
48 - Presenting a model for developing the coaching competencies of the education managers of the 22 districts of the mayor of Tehran
nasim madahi afsaneh zamani moghadam Parivash JaafariThe purpose of this study is to provide a model for developing the coaching competencies of education managers in 22 districts of Tehran Municipality. Due to the nature of the subject, this research is descriptive and survey type. The tools used in this study are open i MoreThe purpose of this study is to provide a model for developing the coaching competencies of education managers in 22 districts of Tehran Municipality. Due to the nature of the subject, this research is descriptive and survey type. The tools used in this study are open interviews and a structured questionnaire. In order to collect information, Delphi interview was conducted with 30 national coaching experts using purposive sampling method. Then, the final model was distributed among 210 managers and education officials of Tehran Municipality using a questionnaire and was evaluated more extensively using structural equations in Amos24 software and validation factor analysis. Based on the results, the variables of coaching action competencies, behavioral-coaching competence, coach-executive competence and coach-monitoring competence were identified as variable dimensions of coaching competency development in Tehran Municipality education managers. The dimensions of the competitor's competencies are: individual and strategic analysis, setting strategic goals and developing operational plans. Transformational leadership, trust, active listening and strong questioning as components of the coach's behavioral competence, empowerment, development and encouragement and guidance in the performance as components of the coach's executive competence, as well as positive monitoring, negative monitoring and feedback as components The coach's ability to monitor was recognized. Manuscript profile -
Open Access Article
49 - Elements and Advantages of Gamification Method in Education: A Meta-Analysis
Reza tohand Mehrangiz alinejad Badr al-Sadat daneshmandGamification has emerged as one of the novel educational methods that aims to improve education by creating a happy, exciting, dynamic and active platform. In fact, this method strengthens different learning channels of learners. Gamification of educational content offe MoreGamification has emerged as one of the novel educational methods that aims to improve education by creating a happy, exciting, dynamic and active platform. In fact, this method strengthens different learning channels of learners. Gamification of educational content offers the concepts and contents in a more convenient way. In this regard, this research was conducted with the aim of exploring the elements and advantages of the gamification method using the meta-analysis approach. The study corpus included national and international studies conducted in the field of gamification, initially 79 national studies and 301 international studies were identified and downloaded, and among them the most relevant sources were selected as the statistical sample, including 30 national studies and 65 international studies (total 95 studies). These sources (articles, dissertations and treatises) were searched in national scientific data bases such as magiran, sid, noormagz, irandoc, ricest as well as comprehensive humanities portal and international scientific data bases such as Proquest, Springer, Sciencedirect, Mdpi, Researchgate, Ieee, Acm, and Google scholars. Next the corpus was analyzed with the aim of identifying the most significant and widely applied elements of the gamification approach and the advantages of this approach. It should be mentioned that the articles presented in the conference were excluded from the study corpus. According to the findings of the research, score, reward, challenge, feedback, leveling, story, interaction and competition with the highest percentage of frequency were the most important and practical elements of gamification in education. Also, creating and promoting interaction and participation, creating motivation, providing a platform for deep learning, improving performance, creating attractiveness and increasing it, developing cognitive growth, creating excitement and vitality, increasing the effectiveness of education, creating a platform for the use of educational technologies, developing social growth, development of soft skills and reduction of disorder were among the benefits of gamification in researches, among these things, creating and promoting interaction and participation, providing a platform for deep learning, creating motivation, improving performance, developing cognitive development, creating excitement and vitality, increasing Effectiveness of education, creation of a platform for the use of educational technologies had the highest frequency percentage. Manuscript profile -
Open Access Article
50 - Identifying the dimensions and components of the work environment curriculum in business organizations (case study: Ports and Maritime Organization)
zahra sharifiblue Kurosh Fathi Vajargah Saeid Safaei Movahhed علیرضا عراقیهThe current research was carried out with the aim of identifying the dimensions and components of the curriculum of the work environment in business organizations in the Ports and Maritime Organization. In terms of purpose, this research was applied and the approach of MoreThe current research was carried out with the aim of identifying the dimensions and components of the curriculum of the work environment in business organizations in the Ports and Maritime Organization. In terms of purpose, this research was applied and the approach of the current research was qualitative and theoretical research. The method of data analysis in the present study was thematic analysis. The results of the analysis show that among the 121 indicators (items) available, 24 main components can be identified. Based on the results of the research, it can be seen that the structure of the curriculum includes target components (needs assessment, cultural adaptation and individual differences and flexibility), content (challenging, proportionality and ease of access) and evaluation (suitability of measurement and evaluation with Objectives, content and learning resources, clarity and transparency of assessment criteria, use of assessment and evaluation methods and flexible assessment. Regarding the factors affecting the design and compilation of the learning management-based work environment curriculum in the Ports and Maritime Organization, the results of the research showed that managerial factors, organizational factors, individual factors, and educational factors are effective factors. Also, the paradigm of learning management compared to educational management includes effective learning components, knowledge orientation, attitude, organizational factors. The principles and assumptions of the curriculum model of the workplace based on learning management, including the components of curriculum axes, development factors, value and characteristics of the curriculum based on learning management, including the components of nature characteristics,learning characteristics and environmental characteristics, were identified Manuscript profile -
Open Access Article
51 - A Peer Mentoring Model for Professors at Teacher Training University: A Grounded Theory Approach
nasrin ozaei alireza assareh Mahmoud Mehrmohammadi mohamadreza emamjomeh gholamali ahmadiPeer mentoring could be mentioned as one of the novel approaches for professional development of university professors. The present study sought to propose a model for the peer mentoring program which could be employed by the professors of Teacher Training University. T MorePeer mentoring could be mentioned as one of the novel approaches for professional development of university professors. The present study sought to propose a model for the peer mentoring program which could be employed by the professors of Teacher Training University. The statistical population included all the professors at the Teacher Training Universities and the sample were selected through criterion sampling which is considered as a variation of purposive sampling. The study data were collected through semi-structured interviews with 15 professors from Teacher Training Universities of Alborz and Tehran provinces. In the next step, open, axial and selective coding methods were used in order to analyze the data. Lincoln and Cuban criteria were used to ensure validity and reliability. The results of the research revealed thirty-five core concepts and eleven selected categories, which were organized and presented in the form of a paradigm model including planning and formulation of macro strategy, needs assessment, attitude, organizational structure redesign, revision and refinement of laws and designing a new performance evaluation system as the core subject and causal conditions (individual and organizational factors), contextual factors (environmental and organizational factors), facilitating intervention conditions (information and media literacy, professional ethics, support, mentoring relationship and job turnover, realism and revision in recruitment policy), limiting intervening conditions (politicization, materialism, weak human resource management, traditional view toward human resources, structural weakness, formalization and temporary view) and outcome (professional growth and development of Teacher Training University professors). Manuscript profile -
Open Access Article
52 - Synthesis of indicators and components of learning culture based on social constructivism
Khojaste Rafi Nejad Aliakbar ajam Hossein momenimahmouei Mehdi zirak zirakPaying attention to learning theories in education plays an important role in curriculum design. The theory of social constructivism as a new theory in school environments is of interest to planners, which requires more attention to its indicators. Therefore, the aim of MorePaying attention to learning theories in education plays an important role in curriculum design. The theory of social constructivism as a new theory in school environments is of interest to planners, which requires more attention to its indicators. Therefore, the aim of the current research is to identify the indicators and components of the learning culture based on the theory of social constructivism. The approach of the current research is qualitative and its method is synthesis research. The research community is all the articles (148 articles) that have been presented in specialized and scientific databases since 2012 and 2013 on learning culture based on the theory of social constructivism. The sample of the research is 33 articles, which were selected based on thematic monitoring, theoretical data saturation, and purposefully. The research data were collected from the qualitative analysis of the studied documents. In order to analyze the data, content analysis was used in the method of categorization based on Roberts' synthesis research model. In order to check the validity of the findings, the recoding of the findings was used based on Scott's method (2012) and the agreement coefficient between the evaluators was calculated as 79%. The components and indicators of the learning culture based on social constructivism in 8 dimensions, 36 axes and 124 categories including goals, learner characteristics, teacher characteristics, teaching-learning approaches, content, environment, evaluation characteristics and The factors became effective. Manuscript profile -
Open Access Article
53 - Identifying The Dimensions and Components of an Effective Education System for Elementary School Managers
Zahra Taghyzade Ghavam Hamideh Reshadatjoo Rasol DavodiThe high capacities of the educational system in developing the potential abilities of the employees could bring about greater credit and value at both individual and social levels which reinforces the mental powers of human beings. This study mainly seeks to identify t MoreThe high capacities of the educational system in developing the potential abilities of the employees could bring about greater credit and value at both individual and social levels which reinforces the mental powers of human beings. This study mainly seeks to identify the dimensions and components of the effective education system for the managers of the elementary school in Tehran. The present study was of a qualitative type based on the grounded theory (self-emergence). The statistical population included experts in the field of educational sciences and educational management, who were selected purposefully through snowball sampling method. Next, 30 experts and practitioners in the field of education were interviewed through semi-structured interviews until reaching the point of theoretical saturation and maximum information. In order to analyze the data, the open, axial and selective coding method was used using MAXQDA software. The resulting data were proposed in the form of a conceptual model as follows: causal conditions (leadership and policy making, management structure), main category (effective training), contextual conditions (executive management), intervening conditions (executive requirements), strategies (educational design, educational planning) and outcome (evaluation and monitoring), which as dimensions of effective education play an important role in fulfilling the mission of school administrators. Finally, based on the findings and results, guidelines for the implementation of the program are recommended. Manuscript profile -
Open Access Article
54 - Identifying Barriers to the optimal implementation of educational needs assessment in National Gas Company of Iran and providing solutions for its improvement
omid oshaghi Mitra Ezati keyvan salehiConsidering the increasing importance and role of educational needs assessment as the first step in the process of optimal training of employees and lack of attention to the comprehensive identification of Barriers to this value-creating process, in the present study, a MoreConsidering the increasing importance and role of educational needs assessment as the first step in the process of optimal training of employees and lack of attention to the comprehensive identification of Barriers to this value-creating process, in the present study, an attempt was made to use a qualitative approach, while deeply analyzing this phenomenon, to identify the Barriers of the educational needs assessment process in The National Gas Company of Iran is identified and solutions for its improvement are suggested. For this purpose, the method of focus groups was used. The field of research was National Gas Company of Iran and the participants were selected fropm among the employees of the training and equipping unit of human resources using the Purposive sampling method. Data collection was done using the focal interview technique and the data saturation level was reached in the fourth focal interview (including 20 people). Data analysis using the theme analysis method resulted in the identification of 207 conceptual propositions, 19 basic themes and 4 main themes. The main themes include individual Barriers, organizational Barriers, managerial Barriers and environmental Barriers. According to the findings of the research, it is necessary to pay attention to the identified Barriers in order to optimally implement the educational needs assessment process in the National Gas Company of Iran; Therefore, at the end, solutions were presented in order to reduce the impact of obstacles on the optimal implementation of the educational needs assessment process and its improvement. Manuscript profile -
Open Access Article
55 - Components and indicators of the model of establishing knowledge management in the organization
َAbbas Zamaani Tabaghdhi Leyla Hoseini Tabahgdehi Hossein momenimahmoueiThe purpose of the current research is to investigate the pattern of establishing knowledge management in the education organization. The approach of the present research is qualitative and its method is a systematic review based on the model of Wright et al. (2007). Th MoreThe purpose of the current research is to investigate the pattern of establishing knowledge management in the education organization. The approach of the present research is qualitative and its method is a systematic review based on the model of Wright et al. (2007). The research community consists of 218 articles about knowledge management in educational organizations, which were presented in reputable scientific journals between 2016 and 2022 and 2013 and 2014. The research sample includes 32 articles that were collected purposefully and selected based on thematic data monitoring. The research data were collected from the qualitative analysis of the studied documents. Based on the data analysis, the competences of the consultants were classified in 4 dimensions and 17 factors. These dimensions include the behavioral dimension (including the characteristics of perceptive skills, media literacy, knowledge management, motivation and commitment), the organizational dimension (including factors; organizational knowledge management strategy, human resource management approach, career path, knowledge management strategies pedagogical, organizational management approach, mentoring and organizational culture), cultural-social dimension (including characteristics such as cultural-social attitude and social capital) and contextual dimension (including factors; providing infrastructure and support) . According to the results, in order to establish knowledge management in the organization, all individual, organizational, and social fields should be considered, and this requires extra-organizational attention. Manuscript profile -
Open Access Article
56 - Leadership development of educational managers in the VUCA world
Leila Rezaei MohammadReza Ahanchian Hossein Jafari Sani Morteza KaramiThis study, which was conducted by a qualitative and phenomenological method, aims to identify the competencies that MA graduated students of Educational Management need for educational leadership in the VUCA situation. In this regard, the data were collected by targete MoreThis study, which was conducted by a qualitative and phenomenological method, aims to identify the competencies that MA graduated students of Educational Management need for educational leadership in the VUCA situation. In this regard, the data were collected by targeted sampling and semi-structured interviews with graduates of Educational Management about their experience of facing with COVID-19 crisis, and the expectations of their employers, views of faculty members and policy makers. The data were analyzed with conceptualization and categorization techniques. Highlighting the challenges of education management in the conditions of VUCA, 25 competencies were extracted which are needed for educational managers. These competencies which include self-regulation, self-leadership, self-efficacy, the ability to use the capacities of society, networking, adaptability, daring, resilience, having skills in emerging technologies, anxiety and distress management, and electronic education and learning management are neglected in most of the competency models for educational managers. Manuscript profile -
Open Access Article
57 - Identifying and Ranking Effectiveness Factors of E-Learning System
Hamidreza Nematollahi ندا محمداسمعیلی Arian Gholipour saeed پاکدلElectronic education and learning is one of the subjects which has recently received great attention in the educational system. Hence it is important to investigate the factors that have a significant impact on the success of the electronic education process and lead to MoreElectronic education and learning is one of the subjects which has recently received great attention in the educational system. Hence it is important to investigate the factors that have a significant impact on the success of the electronic education process and lead to the improvement or reduction of the quality of this educational system. In this regard, the present study ought to provide a comprehensive classification of effective factors in the e-learning system by using the mixed method. First, this study by using the mixed method (theme analysis) method, tried to provide a comprehensive classification of effective factors in the e-learning system, and then by using TOPSIS method the factors were ranked. With regard to the goal, this was an applied research and in terms of time it is a cross-sectional. The participants in the research were employees, professors and students in different fields of Tehran University. 15 individuals were selected after theoretical saturation and the data was collected through semi-structured interviews. By analyzing the obtained data, 43 organizing themes were extracted from the codes, and with further consideration the researchers reached 6 main and comprehensive themes. As the result of ranking revealed, the factors including standardization of e-learning, content interaction, documentation and monitoring of education, and the factors of pedagogy and educational design have the greatest impact, and the factors including increase in perceived usefulness, personal and skill improvement, and network learning have the least impact. Manuscript profile -
Open Access Article
58 - Proposing a Cognitive Model for the Development of Creative Industries Employees (Case Study: IRIB )
Ilya Monzavi Mehdi Sharifi freshteh AminCognitive science can create mechanisms that facilitate and accelerate the process of human resource development. For this purpose, the present article has been done with the aim of compiling and validating the cognitive model of development of creative industry employe MoreCognitive science can create mechanisms that facilitate and accelerate the process of human resource development. For this purpose, the present article has been done with the aim of compiling and validating the cognitive model of development of creative industry employees in the news section of the Islamic Republic of Iran TV. In terms of research approach, heuristic blending method has been used. In the first stage of this research, an analytical method was used, based on which a specific classification of the research process conducted inside and outside the country in the field of organizational repository was done, and then the interview protocol was based on the dimensions and components of The results were compiled from the theoretical foundations and background of the research and the researcher, through the content analysis method, interviewed experts in the field of human resources and using the content analysis steps, a conceptual model in five conceptual layers, category O and codes were obtained. It includes all the experts in the news section of the Islamic Republic of Iran TV and a statistical sample was made available to 20 experts of this organization. The results of the research showed that according to the interviews conducted and the process of content analysis, the dimensions include: 1- Psychological development of employees, 2- Behavioral development of employees, 3- Skills development of employees, 4- Development Employee analysis and 5-Employee support development, which was presented in the form of a schematic model. Manuscript profile -
Open Access Article
59 - Principles and Standards of Professional Ethics of Educational Managers: A Mixed-Method Study
hamid falahi rasoul saediThis study seeks to investigate and discover the principles and standards of professional ethics for educational managers along with the related challenges. The research approach was quantitative-qualitative (mixed method). The statistical population in the qualitative MoreThis study seeks to investigate and discover the principles and standards of professional ethics for educational managers along with the related challenges. The research approach was quantitative-qualitative (mixed method). The statistical population in the qualitative phase included the principals of boys' high schools in one district of Sanandaj (Iran). Consequently, 8 individuals were selected as the study sample using the purposeful sampling method and phenomenological strategy. The study data were collected through conducting interviews including open-ended questions. The findings revealed: a) the concepts of professional ethics that educational managers adhere to with regard to the specific regulations of a profession, religious principles and values, and social norms; b) principles such as self-management, having a vision, professional capabilities, respect, commitment, and responsibility in the job; c) challenges such as structural challenges (lack of comprehensive standard, contradiction between administrative regulations, centralized management, ambiguity of goals) and individual challenges (passivity, limited visions). In order to collect the data, interviews were conducted with managers to obtain their views toward principles and standards of professional ethics, and they were asked if they adhere to these principles. Next, the data obtained from interviews were compiled and implemented in the form of a researcher-made questionnaire which was divided into two aspects: occupational principles and the other pedagogical principles. In the quantitative phase, the community (n=283) included all the teachers, assistants, and principals of boys' high schools in one district of Sanandaj. Using convenience sampling method, 163 individuals were selected as the study sample. Confirmatory factor analysis, one-sample t-test, and Friedman's test were used for data analysis. Finally, according to the results of the one-sample t-test, higher than average level of commitment was reported for managers. Also, the researcher-made questionnaire. Additionally, the results obtained through the questionnaire confirmed the results of the interviews. Manuscript profile -
Open Access Article
60 - Designing a framework for educational online mentoring based on knowledge sharing for key occupations in the transportation industry
abdulah afshar ghasem salimi rahmatallah marzooghi mehdi mohammadi Maryam Shafiei SarvestaniIn recent decades, various strategies for the development of human capital have been proposed by leading organizations. One of the best tools from the point of view of human resource specialists for this is the mentoring program. In addition, technological changes in or MoreIn recent decades, various strategies for the development of human capital have been proposed by leading organizations. One of the best tools from the point of view of human resource specialists for this is the mentoring program. In addition, technological changes in organizational environments have doubled the importance of paying attention to online mentoring. The purpose of the present research was to provide a framework for educational online mentoring based on knowledge sharing for key occupations in the transportation industry. The current research is qualitative and based on the interpretive paradigm, which was designed using the method of meta-synthesis and qualitative case study. In the beginning, 23 articles were selected using the meta- synthesis method and after the stages of quality assessment, which were in accordance with the accepted standards, were examined. In the next stage, in the case study, using the method of purposive sampling, interviews were conducted with 30 people who were experts in the field of transportation industry. Then the articles obtained from the method of meta- synthesis and the articles of the interviews were analyzed and summarized. The results of the meta- synthesis and case study showed that the components of organizational culture, financial and budget resources, evaluation and control, support, communication, human resources, planning, organizational structure, environmental conditions, information and communication technologies are the dimensions of the original model of educational online mentoring. Also, each of these components includes sub-components that define the effectiveness of writing. Manuscript profile -
Open Access Article
61 - Factors Affecting Self-Empowerment of Employees in Private Hospitals in Iran
sahar nazifkar mojtaba amiri Arian GholipourThe purpose of this study was to identify the factors which affect the self-empowerment of employees in private hospitals in Iran and it was conducted by combining qualitative (data base) and quantitative (survey) methods. The statistical population were selected for bo MoreThe purpose of this study was to identify the factors which affect the self-empowerment of employees in private hospitals in Iran and it was conducted by combining qualitative (data base) and quantitative (survey) methods. The statistical population were selected for both qualitative and quantitative parts. In the qualitative phase 40 individuals were selected. From this sample, 20 individuals were managers and employees of private hospitals and 20 individuals were university professors and experts in the field of management. The data in this part was collected through interviews which continued until theoretical saturation was reached. In the quantitative phase, using Cochran's formula, 293 individuals were selected randomly. The data collected from the interviews were analyzed through the grounded theory and the data from the questionnaire were analyzed using SPSS statistical software. The findings revealed that self-empowerment could be considered as a psychological phenomenon based on individual activism. This refers to a process where a set of causal factors (individual and organizational factors or, in other words, internal and external factors), contextual factors (including cultural-social and organizational factors), intervening organizational factors (including organizational justice and organizational transformation and modernization) involve in its formation. Among the mentioned factors, the respondents offered a better evaluation of individual factors compared to organizational factors regarding the casual factors, of organizational nature compared to cultural and social factors in terms of the contextual factors, and of organization change and update compared to organizational justice in terms of intervening factors. Manuscript profile -
Open Access Article
62 - Strategic Planning Model Based on Innovation: An Approach for The Development of Human Resources of the Organization
Mohammad Tafreshei Alireza Manzari tavakkoli sanjar salajeghe ayob sheikhyIn the leading organizations and multinational companies, attending to the new approaches of strategic organizational planning is the main concerns regarding the development of human resources. Therefore, the main goal of this study was to identify the strategic plannin MoreIn the leading organizations and multinational companies, attending to the new approaches of strategic organizational planning is the main concerns regarding the development of human resources. Therefore, the main goal of this study was to identify the strategic planning model based on organizational innovation for the development of human resources. The approach adopted was qualitative and its method was research synthesis. The research corpus included all articles (124 articles) accessible from 2012 to 2023 that were published in specialized and scientific databases about strategic planning based on organizational innovation. The final sample of the research was 31 articles, which have been selected based on thematic monitoring, theoretical saturation of data, and in a purposive way. The research data was collected from the qualitative analysis of the documents under study. By analyzing the data, the components and indicators of the strategic planning model based on organizational innovation were organized in 6 dimensions, 18 axes and 60 categories. The selected axes in this field included six selected components of managerial components, functional components in the organization, strategic evaluation, ethical-cultural components, structural components and identification of organizational challenges and resources. Therefore, considering the results for strategic planning, it is important to pay attention to internal and external indicators. Manuscript profile -
Open Access Article
63 - Presenting a model for human resource development based on the statement of the second step of the revolution: a qualitative research
Naser Mirsepassi Mohammad bagher Reza alizadeh Karam alah danehfardHuman resources is an important and influential factor in the success and development of organizations and societies, and the development of human resources is a process that updates this important capital and keeps it equipped with the required competencies. On the oth MoreHuman resources is an important and influential factor in the success and development of organizations and societies, and the development of human resources is a process that updates this important capital and keeps it equipped with the required competencies. On the other hand, the coordination and compatibility of human resources development policies and the general policies of the country is an undeniable necessity. The purpose of the current research is to provide a model for the development of human resources based on the statement of the second step of the revolution. For this purpose, the qualitative research method and the content analysis method of the interviews and the text of the second step statement have been used. Based on the findings in the axis of dimensions, 3 basic dimensions (individual, organization, society), in the dimension of components 16 main components (empowerment, career planning, needs, motivations, needs assessment, goal setting, education design, information and communication system, maintenance, selection and application, content of training, implementation of programs, evaluation, culture, values and requirements of the society/organization) and in terms of indicators, 9 basic indicators (all-round growth, proper management of the material and spiritual capacities of the country , emphasizing the ideals of the revolution, justice-oriented, anti-corruption, research-oriented and science-oriented, coordination and coherence of actions and policies, participation and cooperation and realism) were identified for the human resources development model based on the second step statement. Manuscript profile -
Open Access Article
64 - A Model of Reverse Coaching in Start-up Businesses through Improving Human Resources Skill Gap
maryam javanmard Seyed Najmeddin mousavi Mohammad Hakkak Amir Houshang NazaripourIn today's era, human resources are an integral part of various organizations, businesses and industries on their way toward their goals. With the advent of growing start-up and online businesses, competition in this field have increased and there is a need for such bus MoreIn today's era, human resources are an integral part of various organizations, businesses and industries on their way toward their goals. With the advent of growing start-up and online businesses, competition in this field have increased and there is a need for such businesses to adapt, harmonize and synchronize employees with the latest level of skills, innovations and technologies available internationally. This seeks to fill in the employees’ skill gap. And reverse coaching is one of the potential tools provided to speed up and facilitate it. In the same line, this article aims to present a model of reverse coaching in start-up businesses with the approach of improving the skill gap of human resources. In terms of the research approach, the qualitative method, especially the foundational data theory method, was used. First, the researcher prepared an interview protocol based on the dimensions and components obtained from the theoretical foundations and background of the research, and then through the data theory method of the foundation, 15 managers, entrepreneurs and owners of start-up businesses were interviewed. These 15 individuals were selected purposefully until reaching theoretical saturation. The results of the research showed that the causal variables fall into two main categories, including managerial and organizational arrangements. Background variables include two categories of information and communication infrastructure development and strategic analysis of the business space. The key variables include the categories of coaching, improving the skill gap; intervening variables include the category of positive stimuli, controlling stimuli and negative stimuli; strategic variables include individual creativity, extending justice and negation of discrimination, participation-oriented in the organization and organizational knowledge management, and outcome variables include arming creative employees, being equipped with efficient and safe systems, and becoming a learning organization. Manuscript profile -
Open Access Article
65 - Designing a knowledge management system deployment model in the social security organization of Hormozgan province
Reza Baranimashahrani Mehdi Bagheri payam paslariThe purpose of the present research is to design a knowledge management system deployment model in the social security organization of Hormozgan province. The current research method is a qualitative type of foundation data. The study community consists of experts in th MoreThe purpose of the present research is to design a knowledge management system deployment model in the social security organization of Hormozgan province. The current research method is a qualitative type of foundation data. The study community consists of experts in the field of knowledge management, employees with 10 years of experience and above, heads of departments and deputies of the social security organization of Hormozgan province. Theoretical sampling of the targeted type was used to select people. Data coding was done using Max Kyuda software. The findings of the research using the coding process showed that 177 primary codes in the form of the model of effective factors (causal and contextual, intervention, strategy and consequence) are effective on the establishment of the knowledge management system in the social security organization of Hormozgan province, and 147 primary codes as Model evaluation indicators were selected. These codes were included in the concepts and key categories according to the findings of the research, the categories of "participatory management, professional competence of employees, the organization's mission and government support" as causal conditions, the categories of "information and management systems, strategy and leadership, education and training, design of courses Training and empowerment of employees" as a strategy and 6 categories (strengthening self-regulation skills, strengthening job motivation, increasing organizational commitment, flexibility in communication, entrepreneurship and innovation, improving organizational performance) have been calculated as the consequences of establishing a knowledge management system in the social security organization. . Manuscript profile -
Open Access Article
66 - Presenting a model in order to improve the professional qualification of human resources managers of National Bank of Iran
Abbasali Samadianbarzaki mahmoud safari Masome OladianThe current research is designing a model to improve the professional qualification of human resources managers of the National Bank of Iran. The method of this research is practical in terms of purpose and it was done by mixed-exploratory (qualitative-quantitative) met MoreThe current research is designing a model to improve the professional qualification of human resources managers of the National Bank of Iran. The method of this research is practical in terms of purpose and it was done by mixed-exploratory (qualitative-quantitative) method. The statistical population in the qualitative section included senior managers of human resources and professional academic experts. Data collection was done through semi-structured interviews with 15 people from the statistical population who were selected by purposive sampling. The research data were analyzed based on the qualitative analysis process during open, central and selective triple coding through MaxQuda 2020 software. The statistical population in the quantitative part includes the managers, employees and experts of the Human Resources Unit of the National Bank of Iran. Data collection was done through a researcher-made questionnaire from among 291 members of the statistical population who were selected by random sampling. The analysis of the collected data was done in two descriptive and inferential ways through SPSS 16 and Smart PLS software.so results of the qualitative analysis of the professional qualification improvement model of human resource managers with two macro-level dimensions (banking field) including organizational infrastructure components, knowledge management system, development programs in the bank, stakeholders' participation in the design of professional qualifications, organizational attitude in the bank, banking educational strategies It included the components of managers' personality factors, managers' leadership skills, managers' technological knowledge, educational-research skills. Priority and personality factors of managers (with a factor load of 0.775) had the lowest priorityand the micro level) Manuscript profile -
Open Access Article
67 - Factors and Solutions Affecting Success of Development and Improvement Programs for Faculty Members
Mohammad taghi RoodiInvestigating factors and solutions that affect development and improvement programs for faculty members could influence the effectiveness of these programs and improve the quality of higher education services. Therefore, the aim of this research is to identify the effe MoreInvestigating factors and solutions that affect development and improvement programs for faculty members could influence the effectiveness of these programs and improve the quality of higher education services. Therefore, the aim of this research is to identify the effective factors and solutions that play an important role in development and improvement programs of faculty members. The present research was conducted with the qualitative content analysis method. The research participants included faculty members of universities and higher education institutions in Tehran and 15 individuals were selected as the study sample and semi-structured interviews were conducted. The participants were selected by purposeful and criterion sampling and the data were analyzed with Thematic analysis method. According to the findings of the research, 6 effective factors and 20 solutions were identified, including: background factor (including: providing facilities, creating and strengthening growth centers, persuading managers and attracting professors' participation), planning factor (including: adjusting the workload of professors, revitalizing and strengthening all kinds of methods, using all kinds of teaching delivery methods and scheduling), the content factor (including: providing practical content, the communication of educational topics and the regulation of all-round promotion and development) the communication factor and cooperation (including: creating learning styles, creating opportunities for cooperation and participation, and improving communication between planners and professors), motivational factor for development (including: salaries and wages, providing training and development incentives and persuading professors), support factor and follow-up (including: supporting training in practice, continuity of development and evaluation programs). Attending to the factors which determine the level of success for these programs and using the solutions presented in the current research could lead to higher effectiveness and improvement of the programs. Manuscript profile -
Open Access Article
68 - A Learning Framework for Knowledge-Based Enterprises: A Meta-Synthesis
Alireza javanbakht Nahid Naderibeni Jabar Babashahi Saeid Safaei MovahhedIn knowledge-based enterprises, the main capital is knowledge, and it is necessary to benefit from this capital by having knowledgeable employees who are lifelong learners. However, traditional learning approaches do not meet the needs of these enterprises. Based on thi MoreIn knowledge-based enterprises, the main capital is knowledge, and it is necessary to benefit from this capital by having knowledgeable employees who are lifelong learners. However, traditional learning approaches do not meet the needs of these enterprises. Based on this, the aim of the present study was to provide a suitable learning framework for knowledge-based enterprises. In order to achieve this goal, the meta-synthesis qualitative method of selection and in-depth analysis of the subject literature were employed based on the seven steps of Sandolowski and Barso. By reviewing the literature, 250 identified sources were analyzed using meta-synthesis method. The results indicated that the components of extra-organizational environment, organizational environment, the essence of knowledge-based enterprises and learning approaches are important aspects of the learning framework of knowledge-based enterprises. Each of these components included sub-components that affect learning in knowledge-based enterprises; therefore, considering the sub-components in the turbulent extra-organizational environment, the organizational environment is affected by the emphasis on agile structure, open culture, collaborative culture, organic job design and independent work space. The essence of knowledge-based enterprises was formed around the orientations including expertise, innovation, team, learning, communication and knowledge. Finally, the three learning approaches of interest in knowledge-based enterprises included experiential learning, self-directed learning, and collaborative learning, which in the literature were the most suitable for this kind of enterprises. Therefore, it can be concluded that paying attention to the identified components along with its sub-components could play an important role in formulating a suitable learning framework for knowledge-based enterprises. Manuscript profile