واکاوی عوامل فردی موثر در انتقال یادگیری کارکنان شهرداری تهران
محورهای موضوعی :مریم حسن پور رودبارکی 1 , مژگان عبدالهی 2 * , علیرضا عراقیه 3 , فاطمه پرسته قمبوانی 4
1 - دانشگاه آزاد اسلامی، واحد کرج، ایران.
2 - دانشگاه آزاد اسلامی کرج
3 - دانشگاه آزاد واحد اسلامشهر
4 - دانشگاه آزاد اسلامي واحد کرج
کلید واژه: آموزش, انتقال یادگیری, یادگیری, عوامل فردی, محیط کار.,
چکیده مقاله :
هدف این مطالعه، شناسایی و بررسی عوامل فردی مؤثر در انتقال یادگیری به محیط کار برای بهبود عملکرد و توسعه شایستگی های مرتبط با حوزه ی شغلی می باشد. روش پژوهش پیمایشی و جامعه ی آماری کلیه کارکنان حوزه حمل و نقل و ترافیک استان تهران به تعداد 910 نفر می باشد. نمونه آماری به شیوه ی نمونه گیری خوشه ای تک مرحله ای از طریق فرمول کوکران و به تعداد 270 نفر (کارکنانی که حداقل6 ماه و حداکثر یکسال از گذراندن دوره های آموزشی آنها گذشته)، انتخاب شدند. گردآوری داده ها به صورت مطالعات کتابخانه ای و تحقیق میدانی از طریق پرسشنامه ی محقق ساخته با تائید روایی محتوا توسط چند تن از محققان علوم تربیتی و مدیریت و پایایی ابزار با ضریب آلفای کرونباخ (0.77) بدست آمد. به منظور شناسایی عوامل فردی از تحلیل عامل اکتشافی و تحلیل عامل تاییدی و برای تعیین مناسب ترین عامل ها از چرخش واریماکس استفاده شد. نتایج حاصل نشان داد: مولفه های خودکارآمدی، انتظارات از نتایج عملکرد، توانایی شناختی، نگرش شغلی، جهت‌گیری، تعهد سازمانی، آمادگی یادگیرنده، ویژگی‌های شخصیتی، منبع کنترل، احساس مثبت، خودآگاهی، ویژگی‌های جمعیت شناختی، دریافت از منابع یادگیری، گشودگی تجربه، انگیزش انتقال، سودمندی و ارزش ادراک شده و هدف محوری غیر از مولفه های مقاومت در برابر تغییر و سطح انگیزش، از عوامل فردی مؤثر بر انتقال یادگیری می‌باشند. براساس نتايج به دست آمده از آزمون فریدمن نیز عامل«تعهد سازمانی» با میانگین 76/12 بیشترین تأثیر و عامل«سطح انگیزش» با میانگین 58/4 کمترین تأثیر را بر انتقال یادگیری داشته است.
The Purpose of this Study is to identify and investigate the individual factors affecting transferring of learning to workplace in order to improve the performance and develop job competencies. It was a descriptive survey research. The population consisted of all staff at Transportation and Traffic Department in Tehran (N= 910). The sample was selected through a single-cluster sampling method through the Cochran formula and 270 employees (employees who were at least 6 months and at most one year after passing their training courses). Data collection was carried out through library studies and field research through a researcher-made questionnaire with content validity confirmation by several researchers in education and management and reliability of the tool, with Cronbach's alpha coefficient (0.77). In order to identify individual factors, exploratory factor analysis and confirmatory factor analysis, Varimax rotation was used to determine the most appropriate factors. The results showed: self-efficacy components, expectations from performance outcomes, cognitive ability, job attitude, orientation, organizational commitment, learner readiness, personality traits, control source, positive feeling, self-awareness, demographic characteristics, reception from learning resources, openness of experience, transfer motivation, perceived usefulness and value and core purpose are individual factors affecting transfer of learning, except the resistance to change and motivation level. According to results of Friedman test, the organizational commitment with the mean of 12.76 and level of motivation (mean=4.58) had the highest and least effect on transferring of learning of staff.
1. Hunter-Johnson YO. When training is not enough: An appeal to the work environment for transfer of training in the Bahamian police force. International Journal of Bahamian Studies. 2013;19(1):3-14.
2. Sabbaghian Z, Akbari S. Comprehensive Organizational Training with adult education approach. Tehran: Samt Publication; 2010.
3. 3.Lobato J. Alternative perspectives on the transfer of learning: History, issues, and challenges for future research. The Journal of the Learning Sciences. 2006;15(4):431-49.
4. Alvelos R, Ferreira AI, Bates R. The mediating role of social support in the evaluation of training effectiveness. European Journal of Training and Development. 2015;39(6):484-503.
5. Abbaspour A, Vafayizadeh M. Pathology of Learning Transmission System: Missing Ring in Training Tracking Process. Conference of Educational and Research Directors; Mashhad Holy2010.
6. Qurat-Ul-Ain Q, Bhutto A, Tunio RA. Factor Affecting the Transfer of Training at the Workplace: Case study of SSGC Ltd, Pakistan. International Journal of Academic Research in Business and Social Sciences. 2017;7(2):2222-6990.
7. Ghanbari C, Morkalani GS, Arefi M, Zandi K. Pathology of Transfer of Learning to the Environment in Government Organizations of Kurdistan Province (A Qualitative Study). Journal of Human Resource Education and Development. 2017;4(12):1-27.
8. Burke LA, Hutchins HM. Training transfer: An integrative literature review. Human resource development review. 2007;6(3):263-96.
9. Baldwin TT, Ford JK. Transfer of training: A review and directions for future research. Personnel psychology. 1988;41(1):63-105.
10. Dhabashi F, Ariati H, Noori A, Akrami N. The relationship between the need for recognition, educational self-efficacy and the motivation for learning / educational motivation, by transferring education among the students of the Entrepreneurship Center of Isfahan University. Entrepreneurship Development. 2014;7(1):173-90.
11. Mwambu DK. Factors Influencing the Transfer of Training As a Driver of Strategic Growth: A Case Study of Kenya Aerotech Limited: United States International University-Africa; 2016.
12. Subedi BS. Emerging Trends of Research on Transfer of Learning. International education journal. 2004;5(4):591-9.
13. Mohammadi M, Jahromi RN, Mokhtari Z, Jahromi AR, Abedi A, Jahromi RN. Evaluation of the Effective Factors on the Transfer of Learning Nursing In-Service Training Courses Based on the Holton Transition Model. Journal of Developmental Education in Medical Sciences. 2016;9(23):83-9.
14. Barnard S. Barriers to employee transfer of learning: University of Johannesburg; 2013.
15. Hamid WW, Saman MM, Saud M. Exploring factors influencing the transfer of training using a grounded theory study: Issues and research agenda. Procedia-Social and Behavioral Sciences. 2012;56:662-72.
16. Lim DH, Johnson SD. Trainee perceptions of factors that influence learning transfer. International journal of training and development. 2002;6(1):36-48.
17. Nazli NNNN, Sipon S, Zumrah AR, Abdullah S. The factors that influence the transfer of training in disaster preparedness training: A review. Procedia-Social and Behavioral Sciences. 2015;192:54-8.
18. Blume BD, Ford JK, Baldwin TT, Huang JL. Transfer of training: A meta-analytic review. Journal of management. 2010;36(4):1065-105.
19. Abdollahi M, Daneshmandi S. The Environment Factors Transfer of Training: Tehran Municipality Employees. International Journal of Learning and Development. 2015;7(3):133-48.
20. Mourakani GS, Daneshmandi S, Maleki H, Sadeghi MS. Studying the Status of Transfer of Learning to Workplace: Case Study. Training & Development Journal. 2015;6(1):36-49.
21. Ayres HW. Factor's related to motivation to learn motivation to learn, and motivations to transfer learning in nursing population: North California State University in Partial; 2005.
22. Khan I, Mufti S, Nazir NA. Transfer of training: A reorganized review on work environment and motivation to transfer. International Journal of Management, Knowledge and Learning. 2015;4(2):197-219.
23. Ismaili A, Taheri M, Vinnese G. Facilitate the transfer of learning from the path of professionalism: partner and manager support. Journal of Human Resource Education and Development. 2014;1(1):31-45.
24. Khorasani A, Morkalani GS, Mokhtari Z. Evaluation of the role of the individual factor in the effective transfer of employee in service training to the workplace. Journal of Educational and Study Studies. 2017;9(1):109-28.
25. Travis Hichs E. Individual and Situational Factors Affecting Transfer of Training in a Call Center Environment: Faculty of the Graduate School of the University of Louisville in Partial (University of Kentucky); 2006.
26. Bansal A, Thakur M. The impact of perception of organizational transfer climate factors and trainees’ characteristics on training transfer: The context of mergers and acquisitions. Journal of International Business and Economics. 2013;1(1):51.
27. Suleiman W, Dassanayake MS, Othman AEA. Roles of Trainee Characteristics and Work Environment in Training Transfer: A Conceptual Extension of Baldwin and Ford Model with Job Attitude Factors in Nigerian Context. 2016.
28. Dianati M, Erfani M. Competencies, concepts and applications. Tadbir Monthly. 2009;206:14-9.
29. Ghasemi B, Abedini S, Abedini M. The Study of the Relationship between Personality Characteristics and Educational Motivation of First-Level Female Students of Education in Bandar Abbas Province. Journal of Psychology and Education. 2016;2(10):117-56.
30. Mourakani GS, Hosseini N. Organizational education: Transfer of learning to the workplace. Tehran: Bavaredalat Publication; 2013.
31. Usbashi A, Abili K, Kharrazi S, Sobhaninejad M. Organizational factors for learning transfer to work environment (Case study: National Iranian Gas Company). Quarterly Journal of Human Resource Education and Development. 2016;3(9):21-45.
32. K.Steward R, Dickinson N. Transfer of Learning: Annotated Biblioghraphy ACCWICS Institute on Transfer of Learning to Support Systems Change in Child Welfare. University of Maryland, School of Social Work. 2013:1-9.
33. Mirkamali SM, Niemour AM. Identifying the factors associated with the transfer of training to the workplace from the point of view of the experts of the Petrochemical Research and Technology Company using the Delphi method. Journal of Management Improvement 2014;8(2):73-98.
34. Taqavifard M, Rahimian H, Najafi A. Investigating the Status of Transfer of Education and Prioritizing Effective Factors in the Petrochemical Industry with Group A Hierarchy Process Technique. Quarterly Journal of Human Resource Education and Development. 2015;2(6):75-101.
35. Lotfi H, Ahanchian MR, Karami M. Transfer of learning from the teaching environment to the workplace in organizations and the factors affecting it. The first national conference on modern approaches to business management; Yazd University 2014.
36. Holton III EF, Bates RA, Ruona WE. Development of a generalized learning transfer system inventory. Human resource development quarterly. 2000;11(4):333-60.
37. Najafi A, Taghavifard M, Zarrin H, Bashokouh A. Effective Factors on Motivations of Training Transfer in National Petrochemical Companies and Its Prioritization by Group AHP Technique. Journal of Management and Planning in Educational Systems 2017;10(1):29-48.
38. Abili K, Kharrazi S, Sobhaninejad M, Uosbashi A. An Effective Model of Learning Transfer in the direction of return on investment in human resource development with an emphasis on urban management. Journal of Urban Economics and Management. 2015;3(11):79-98.
39. B.Merriam S, Leahy B. Learning Transfer: A Review of the Reseach in Adult Education & Training. PAACE Journal of Lifelong Learning. 2005;1(14):1-24.
40. Noe RA, Schmitt N. The influence of trainee attitudes on training effectiveness: Test of a model. Personnel psychology. 1986;39(3):497-523.
41. Heidari H, Naqshbandi T, Tavassoli D, Alipour R. Pathology of in-service training courses of Shahid Beheshti University staff based on Halton Model. Second National Conference on Pathology of Organizational Training with Application Approach Based on Executives Experiences in Organizations. Tehran: Afagh Industrial Co; 2012.
42. Karami M, Rahmanizadeh D, Joveid B. Impact of Pervasive Characteristics, Educational Design and Work Environment on Learning Transition in the Banking Industry. Quarterly Journal of Human Resource Education and Development. 2014;1(1):135-54.
43. Dorji T. Transfer of Learning from the Out-country Training Programs (Ministry of Education, Bhutan): Royal Government of Bhutan: University of Canberra; 2005.
44. Tziner A, Haccoun RR, Kadish A. Personal and situational characteristics influencing the effectiveness of transfer of training improvement strategies. Journal of occupational psychology. 1991;64(2):167-77.
45. Mohammadi M, Naserijahromi R, Mokhtari Z, Raskhjahromi A, Abedi A, Naserijahromi R. Evaluation of the Effective Factors on the Transfer of Learning of Nursing In-Service Training Courses to the Workplace Based on the Halton Transition Model. Journal of Medical Education Development. 2016;9(23):83-9.