An Investigation and Pathology of Organizational Training for Engineers in Water and Electricity Industry Based on ADDIE
Subject Areas :
zainab
sharaf
1
(phd student of Curriculum Planning, Department of Educational Sciences, Faculty of Educational Sciences and Psychology, Isfahan University, Iran.)
Mohammad reza
Nili Ahmadabadi
2
(Associate Professor, Isfahan University of Educational Sciences and Psychology, Faculty of Educational Sciences and Psychology, Isfahan University, Iran)
Mohammad Javad
Liaghatdar
3
(Professor, Department of Educational Sciences, Faculty of Educational Sciences and Psychology, Isfahan University, Iran.)
Keywords: organizational training, assessment, model (ADDIE), pathology, water and electricity industry.,
Abstract :
Organizational training could play a significant role in keeping the knowledge, skills and attitudes of employees updated, if it is conducted based on scientific principles and methods and considered as an empowering factor. In this regard, the present study seeks to evaluate and identify the limitations of the organizational training of engineers in the water and electricity industry. To this aim a mixed method was used including survey method in the quantitative phase and phenomenology in the qualitative phase. The research tool in the quantitative part was a researcher-made questionnaire and in the qualitative part it was a semi-structured interview. The participants in the quantitative part included trained engineers, 900 individuals in the year 2021, and in the qualitative part there were teachers and employers in the water and electricity industry. In the quantitative section, 269 individuals were selected by simple random sampling using Morgan's table, and in the qualitative section, 20 individuals were interviewed based on the theoretical saturation level. For analyzing the quantitative data, SPSS software was used and for qualitative data analysis, thematic analysis method was used. According to the findings of the quantitative part of the research, the current state of organizational training of engineers in the water and electricity industry in all 5 dimensions of education is at the average and below average levels. On the other hand, based on the findings of the qualitative part, the main limitations of the organizational occupational training system include process limitations, motivational, cultural and administrative structure. The results revealed that the organizational training of the water and electricity industry does not meet the desired quality levels; cultural problems and inattention to the academic degrees, lack of motivational incentives, structural-administrative problems and process problems and non-compliance of organizational trainings with scientific and logical approaches could be mentioned as some of the factors leading to the current situation.
1. Ebrahimi Koushk Mehdi S, Fazel R, Ahanchian MR. The Phenomenology of Organizational Training: the lived Experience of Staff in Ferdowsi University of Mashhad, Quarterly Journal of Training & Development of Human Resources , (2016) 3(9), 47-66. [Persian]
2. Rostami H, Nasr Isfahani AR, Neyestani MR. Evaluation of Acquired Knowledge and Skills by Employees’ and Capability of Trainers of In-service Training Courses in Agricultural Jihad Organization of Markazi Province. Agricultural Extension and Education Research, (2017). 10(1), 31-40. [Persian]
3. Nave Ibrahim AR, Pourkrimi J. Providing a conceptual model for the improvement of faculty members of universities and higher education centers, Journal of Research in Educational Systems, (2008). 2(5), 101-120. [Persian]
4. Garavan TN, Hogan C, O'Donnell A C. Handbook of Training and Development: A" best Practice" Guide. Pentagon Press, (2006).
5. Fathi Vajargah K. Introduction to planning training staff. Tehran search term. (2013).
6. Landy FJ, Conte JM. Work in the 21st century: An introduction to industrial and organizational psychology. John Wiley & Sons; 2016 Jan 11.
7. Boahin P, Hofman WA. Perceived effects of competency-based training on the acquisition of professional skills. International Journal of Educational Development, (2014). 36, 81-89.
8. Baker M. Training Effectiveness Assessment, Naval Air Warfare Center Training System Division, (1999).
9. Cheung L. Using the ADDIE model of instructional design to teach chest radiograph interpretation. Journal of Biomedical Education, (2016). 1-6.
10. Clark D. Introduction to Instructional System Design. (2006).
11. Dinarvand H. Instructional Design Effective, (2011), Tehran, Ayez. [Persian]
12. rahimi B, talbazedh M, mehri D. Pathology of curriculum of the In-service training courses employee of aerial university of science and tech of shahid satari based on the pattern (ADDIE) (Explanatory Blend Study). Qualitative Research in Curriculum, (2017). 3(8), 149-201. [Persian]
13. Bee F, Bee R. Learning needs analysis and evaluation. Chartered Institute of Personnel and Development. (2003).
14. rafiei N, Eghbalian Nouranizadeh P. Evaluation of E-learning Courses based on Educational Design Elements from ADDIE in Isfahan University of Medical Sciences. Educational Development of Judishapur, (2022). 13(1), 85-96. [Persian]
15. Dehghanzadeh H, Dehghanzadeh H, Salehi Najafabadi F. The Effects of Teacher’s Video as an Emotional Strategy on Students’ Learning in Multimedia Learning Environments. Journal of Education and Learning Studies. (2022). 14(1), 204-219. [Persian]
16. Shams G, Ghahramani M, Davari Aghdam F. Evaluation of the strategic training & development courses according to the Noe Strategic Training & Development Model: (The case study: Rah-e Roshd Educational Complex). Journal of Management and Planning In Educational System, (2021). 14(2), 73-112. [Persian]
17. Alavi S, Hoseeinpour M, Mehralizadeh Y. Identifying the Effective Factors on Improvement of In-Service Training of Managers of Health Vocational Education and Training Centers; A Qualitative Study. Journal of the Iranian Institute for Health Sciences Research, (2021). 20(1), 15-29. [Persian]
18. habibi H, hamrahzade M, jafarian V. Pathology of Organizational Training Management: A Phenomenological Study. Journal of New Approaches in Educational Administration, (2020). 11(44), 55-76. [Persian]
19. Shojaa K, Karami M, Ahanchian M R, Nadi M. Evaluating the Effectiveness of Training Program: Case study, Ferdowsi University of Mashhad. Quarterly Journal of Training and Development of Human Resources, (2017). 4(12), 105-126. [Persian]
20. FathiAzar E, Adib Y, Golparvar F. Phenomenology of Effective Factors and Motivator in Quality of In-Service Training Courses of Teachers. Research in School and Virtual Learning, (2016). 3(12), 47-56. [Persian]
21. Taheri M, Nazari N, Ghiasi S. Organizational learning culture, managerial effectiveness and psychological empowerment: Predictors of learning in the workplace. Journal of Education and Learning Studies, (2016). 8(2), 19-36. [Persian]
22. Mehri D, Gholami M, Moradi S. Quality Evaluation of in-Service Trainings Based on Quality of Services Approach in Shahid Sattari University of Science and Technology. Quarterly Journal of Training and Development of Human Resources, (2015). 2(5), 127-144. [Persian]
23. Hosseini MS, Shami M, Khanifar H. Pathology of In- service Training based on OEM Model (Case: In-service Trainings in Zones of Qom Pedagogy). Organizational Culture Management, (2016). 13(4), 1201-1221. [Persian]
24. Naghshbandi T.Pathology of elements of the curriculum of in-service training courses for employees of Iran Khodro Company based on Ecker's model in 2013. Master's thesis, Shahid Beheshti University, Faculty of Educational Sciences and Psychology, curriculum planning. ( 2014). [Persian]
25. Tirandaz A, Jalali A. Pathology of in-service trainings for employees of government organizations. The second national conference on organizational training with an applied approach based on executive experiences in organizations, (2013). Tehran: Afaq Sanat Institute. [Persian]
26. Baceviciute S, Cordoba A L, Wismer P, Jensen TV, Klausen M, Makransky G. Investigating the value of immersive virtual reality tools for organizational training: An applied international study in the biotech industry. Journal of Computer Assisted Learning, (2022). 38(2), 470-487.
27. Zou W, Hu X, Pan Z, Li C, Cai Y, Liu M. Exploring the relationship between social presence and learners’ prestige in MOOC discussion forums using automated content analysis and social network analysis. Computers in Human Behavior, (2021). 115, 106582.
28. Alfaidi S D A, Elhassan F A M. The Role of In-Service Training Programs in Teachers Development. International Journal of Learning and Teaching, (2020). 6(3), 191-95
29. Ozcan D. Gunduz N. Evaluation of In-service Training Progams of Assciations. Procedia and Behavioral Sciences, (2015). 191, 1028-1033.
30. Iqbak kh, Zafar G, Abbasib M. Evaluation of the effectiveness of the effectiveness of inservice employees training course. (2009). Pakista.
31. Kalbasi A, Nasr AR. The use of hybrid designs in social sciences and humanities researches. Methodology of Social Sciences and Humanities. 2011, 17(67):79-96.